News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Psychedelics Are Challenging the Scientific Gold Standard by nathan_compton on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @07:51PM (#40580101)
You don't need a perfect account to have a reasonable account. You've set up an absurd standard which essentially no knowledge could reasonably meet. I'm not a distinguished neuroscientist, but I've published papers in neuroscience and while we certainly can't provide a full account of the precise details of these brain states, the balance of the physical sciences, including neuroscience, leads me to strongly favor the "machine elves aren't real" hypothesis.
Re:Psychedelics Are Challenging the Scientific Gold Standard by spacetimeuser5 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:46AM (#40582401)
Sorry, dude, but your behavior can be formally comparable to a grandma's at a bazaar selling potatoes rather than someone with a slight quest for fundamental science. Obviously her potatoes are the best, *just because* they're reasonably the best and reasonable resources have been invested in them, and all other potatoes are absurd.

Here're the schematics of some modern computer electronics [1], [2]. Every element, every connection is described in detail and in place. Is this absurd? Under the hood you consider the brain a similar type of computing machine, a bit more complicated, but fundamentally it should be the same. So the relevant schematics should be available. Yet, instead of acknowledging that in order to obtain 90% of information I requested with modern neuroscience methods a person should be effectively dead or brain damaged, you just call it absurd. So have a reasonable way to the bazaar.

Recent advances in physical science [3],[4] have effectively shown that local realism is false. And there is a corpus of research in neuroscience, which I won't discuss here, as well as developed instrumentation and theory in physics (like field theory) which can allow to test these alternative hypotheses, rather than just bluntly stick to one's important subjectively reasonable opinion.

If you are an expert on how the brain generates what's reasonable and unreasonble, do you have queues of developers, chemists, mathematicians, any other types of technologists, who are developing technologies which actually contribute to human civilization, obviously using their brains for this and asking your recommendations on how to tune their technology generation engine(=brain) to generate more and faster? I doubt that even Huberman has any.

[1] https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/electrical-schematic-op... [2] https://www.laptopschematic.com/xinzhizao-schematic-tool-vip... [3] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-universe-is-n... [4] https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2022/press-release...