Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by 2pEXgD0fZ5cF on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @05:30AM
(#40572424)
> [...] we arranged to have five servers shipped to Amsterdam. However, all five servers were lost in the mail.
> These parcels were insured with the shipping provider, but we have been unable to reach the provider for any information regarding the status of the parcels or any resources for filing an insurance claim.
> After several months of attempts, we have ultimately had to write these servers off.
I obviously do not know the details here and it might be perfectly understandable given the full picture, but this chain of events sounds weird and could have used some further explanation.
Because this makes it sound like several thousand dollars worth of important equipment (and possibly important data) went missing and the issue was completely dropped because emails remained unanswered?
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by drewdevault on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @05:39AM
(#40572472)
There was no lost data, and it wasn't just unanswered emails -- several hours on the phone, juggling between subsidiaries on either side of the pond, with no clear responsible party on their end. The customer service for this shipping provider is totally opaque and automated with AI crap throughout. We did eventually get in touch with some humans but they were not ultimately very helpful.
We do have general business insurance and will probably file a claim, but we have two overworked and exhausted staff members, a lot of other priorities, and a budget which is already pretty deeply cut from all of these events, and we just don't have the time and energy to duke it out with an opaque megacorporation right now.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by strogonoff on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @07:29AM
(#40573239)
If a shipping provider loses shipment and refuses to respect the insurance agreement, it sounds like they should be sued for damages. The damages are much more than the cost of the shipment, as the loss itself also undermines operations and causes a lot of financial downside.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by strogonoff on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @07:53AM
(#40573473)
In some jurisdictions, the losing side will have to cover the cost. In some jurisdictions there are also small claims courts, which do not need legal representation.
It’s clear that it caused financial distress whereas as happy paying customer I want SourceHut to continue existing.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by arp242 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:18PM
(#40576838)
The reality is that actually getting your rights is often an enormous hassle, in terms of time, money, and/or stress.
If you're BigCorp™® with a Lawyer Department then that's not really a problem: you just send it off to the lawyers and continue with your day. If you're a private individual and/or small business: it very quickly becomes a trade-off.
So imagine SourceHut sues. And they win. And losing shipping company has to pay all of sourcehut's fees. There is a very real non-zero chance they will just say "lol nope, fuck you". And then what? Basically nothing you can do about it. Even in domestic cases this is true, international cases even more so.
In reality a lot of the world runs on goodwill and voluntary adherence to the rules, with not all that much little stopping bad actors from abusing things.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by strogonoff on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @06:07PM
(#40579456)
I part agree, but that goodwill and adherence also exist thanks to people who are willing to exercise their rights. A shipping company that suddenly can’t operate in a profitable country because they are in violation of court order will lose a lot of money; chances are, they like money.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by arp242 on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @07:14PM
(#40579897)
Yes, I agree; see e.g Alan Bates for a famous example. But I don't think anyone could be faulted for not being Alan Bates and just moving on with their life.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by pentagrama on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @06:21PM
(#40579567)
> could have used some further explanation
They are not obligated to explain what happened in more detail. Your comment sounds like someone speculating about why a celebrity couple broke up when they release a brief public message announcing their separation.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by remram on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @11:47PM
(#40581194)
And this part you quote comes right after a description of how their primary data center failed so badly that they had to completely evacuate it... It does give the impression that they just use cheap unreliable providers across the board.
Not necessarily a bad thing, it might be a calculated risk so they can pass on savings to customers. Still, a strong signal there.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by drewdevault on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @01:40AM
(#40581707)
In retrospect, our datacenter partner in the old datacenter was unreliable. But, we had been there from the start, since I was just hosting a personal server there pre-SourceHut, and during the incident they egregiously violated their SLA with us -- we had reason to expect better from them.
We're much more confident in our AMS partner, though.
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by oldpersonintx on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @05:15AM
(#40572322)
we arranged to have five servers shipped to Amsterdam. However, all five servers were lost in the mail. These parcels were insured with the shipping provider, but we have been unable to reach the provider for any information regarding the status of the parcels or any resources for filing an insurance claim
what? this sounds incredibly fishy. you don't just walk away from "losing" $25k (at least) worth of anything...there is either malfeasance here or incredible stupidity (either case is suspect enough to warn off of using sr.ht)
get a lawyer, go to the shipper/insurer's office...something...if someone ripped me off on that level I wouldn't just be shrugging and walking away
I understand you might be getting memory-holed by the shipper...but the insurance company as well? I don't believe you
and don't tell me I don't understand the time-value of money...you don't let stuff like this slide, this is basic
I am a paying customer and this post leaves me dismayed wrt using sr.ht
it seems like you (Drew) just want to horse around on harelang etc and are letting sr.ht rot...I was one of your earliest paying customers and I will be transitioning away and maybe you should rethink why you bothered starting sr.ht at all
Re:The state of SourceHut and our plans for the future
by malicka on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @08:32AM
(#40573821)
The downside to transparency – someone will bad-faith you into oblivion for telling the truth.
Personally, even if the fall-out of losing the servers hasn’t been perfectly-and-neatly handled (civil suit, money back, etc.), I am impressed at the resilience they’ve had; this is something that very easily could’ve wiped out other projects, but they’re still here and they’ve managed to raise capacity. The transparency is also greatly appreciated.
> These parcels were insured with the shipping provider, but we have been unable to reach the provider for any information regarding the status of the parcels or any resources for filing an insurance claim.
> After several months of attempts, we have ultimately had to write these servers off.
I obviously do not know the details here and it might be perfectly understandable given the full picture, but this chain of events sounds weird and could have used some further explanation.
Because this makes it sound like several thousand dollars worth of important equipment (and possibly important data) went missing and the issue was completely dropped because emails remained unanswered?
We do have general business insurance and will probably file a claim, but we have two overworked and exhausted staff members, a lot of other priorities, and a budget which is already pretty deeply cut from all of these events, and we just don't have the time and energy to duke it out with an opaque megacorporation right now.
It’s clear that it caused financial distress whereas as happy paying customer I want SourceHut to continue existing.
If you're BigCorp™® with a Lawyer Department then that's not really a problem: you just send it off to the lawyers and continue with your day. If you're a private individual and/or small business: it very quickly becomes a trade-off.
So imagine SourceHut sues. And they win. And losing shipping company has to pay all of sourcehut's fees. There is a very real non-zero chance they will just say "lol nope, fuck you". And then what? Basically nothing you can do about it. Even in domestic cases this is true, international cases even more so.
In reality a lot of the world runs on goodwill and voluntary adherence to the rules, with not all that much little stopping bad actors from abusing things.
They are not obligated to explain what happened in more detail. Your comment sounds like someone speculating about why a celebrity couple broke up when they release a brief public message announcing their separation.
SourceHut are not obligated to post this blog post, but since they did, we are reading it.
Not necessarily a bad thing, it might be a calculated risk so they can pass on savings to customers. Still, a strong signal there.
We're much more confident in our AMS partner, though.
what? this sounds incredibly fishy. you don't just walk away from "losing" $25k (at least) worth of anything...there is either malfeasance here or incredible stupidity (either case is suspect enough to warn off of using sr.ht)
get a lawyer, go to the shipper/insurer's office...something...if someone ripped me off on that level I wouldn't just be shrugging and walking away
I understand you might be getting memory-holed by the shipper...but the insurance company as well? I don't believe you
and don't tell me I don't understand the time-value of money...you don't let stuff like this slide, this is basic
I am a paying customer and this post leaves me dismayed wrt using sr.ht
it seems like you (Drew) just want to horse around on harelang etc and are letting sr.ht rot...I was one of your earliest paying customers and I will be transitioning away and maybe you should rethink why you bothered starting sr.ht at all
Personally, even if the fall-out of losing the servers hasn’t been perfectly-and-neatly handled (civil suit, money back, etc.), I am impressed at the resilience they’ve had; this is something that very easily could’ve wiped out other projects, but they’re still here and they’ve managed to raise capacity. The transparency is also greatly appreciated.
I find this heartening. Godspeed to them!