All I'm saying is that none of this makes it even slightly remotely possible that it is anything other than a hallucination.
And note: they are not hallucinating a higher level of intelligence, they are hallucinating a way to accept their own trauma in the form of an entity that appears more intelligent. Just like when writers create a super-intelligent alien in a movie, they don't actually create something more intelligent than humans.
Now, if they were seeing an entity that explained new ways of solving partial differential equations to them, then I would say that the external entity hypothesis merits some investigation.
The word "hallucination" sometimes has some negative connotations that suggest they are deceitful or useless experiences that you should ignore and forget. I'm not trying to say that at all. I do think it's quite possible that any therapeutic effect is entirely due to these experiences, and, if so, they should be encouraged, not ignored.
What, specifically, separates a "fact" from a "non fact" in this specific context?
There are a few different classes/categories you'll see, but not many.
> Facts are true statements.
Do (non-specialized, as in scientific facts) facts require a proof, or not? And if not....
> Questioning what your interlocuter thinks a "fact" is isn't going to move the debate forward in any useful way.
Perhaps (is that future you see the real thing?), it may provide value though.
Is there a difference between a fact and a scientific fact (from a Philosophy of Science perspective)?
> A non fact is something that blatantly contradicts this body of knowledge without any credible new evidence.
Can you cite anything authoritative that supports this claim?
And....are "fact" and "non fact" the only two options?
And while any positive statement is either a fact or a "non fact", there are plenty of things we don't know the truth of (P=NP? Gravity is quantum?), and something that today seems a fact can be a non-fact tomorrow, though this rarely happens in physics (often, some preconditions just need to be added to make the older "fact" still correct).
I'm not sure what you want me to cite. Why I believe in this definition of "fact"?
------------
fact
/fak(t)/
noun
1. a thing that is known or proved to be true.
2. information used as evidence or as part of a report or news article
------------
I was under the impression that a distinguishing factor of "fact" was Truth, now that I know that mere information is a fact, it explains a whole bunch of what confused me about this world.
-
Even more interesting:
------------
truth
/tro͞oTH/
noun
1. the quality or state of being true.
2. that which is true or(!) in accordance with fact (see above) or reality
3. a fact or belief that is accepted as true
------------
I feel like I should feel silly.
I wonder if this type of thing will actually end up helping neuroscience research as well, seeing as how some of these substances seem to push higher level concepts than what is typically easily induced in an fMRI. If they turn out to be safe for human use, they should be usable in this setting as well.
And yes, of course an entity your brain is hallucinating "knows" about your memories. It's you talking to yourself.