News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If English was written like Chinese (1999) by latentsea on Monday June 03, 2024 @08:50PM (#40569520)
It does, but the loanwords from Chinese vastly outnumber those, so the influence of Chinese words on Japanese is pretty undeniable.
Re:If English was written like Chinese (1999) by umanwizard on Monday June 03, 2024 @10:08PM (#40570007)
Fair enough.
Re:If English was written like Chinese (1999) by adrian_b on Tuesday June 04, 2024 @01:46AM (#40571069)
The amount of Chinese words is usually much greater in written Japanese or in legal/technical/scientific jargon than in casual spoken Japanese.

The proportion of Chinese words also depends on the manner of accounting the compound words and the inflected words.

I have seen the claim that the modern Japanese vocabulary consists roughly of 45% Chinese words, 45% native Japanese words, 8% English words and 2% words borrowed from other languages, mainly from Portuguese or other European languages.

I do not know what assumptions have been used to compute these percentages, but they are similar to the frequencies of the words encountered in many modern Japanese texts.

There are a lot of modern Japanese words that are composed from two or three or four or even more Chinese words. If all the compounds would be counted separately, the proportion of Chinese words in the Japanese vocabulary could increase a lot.

Re:If English was written like Chinese (1999) by numpad0 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @09:53AM (#40597389)
btw this is true for historical arguments, but actual size of workable shared vocabulary in common use is tiny - famously "手紙(hand paper)" means postal letters in Japanese, and toilet paper in Chinese.