Japan is definitely technologically behind. I am not arguing against that. But let's not exaggerate here.
Bank transfers are instant and I don't need to fill in any forms (other than the receiving bank account info) or justify anything, and I get cashbacks both in form of cash and points that I can use at the konbini, etc.
I also don't need to give out any papers showing where I live, instead they send a kind of sealed postcard to my stated address to verify it.
I don't know much about 3-D secure, is that like MFA? If so I guess I have that too, but you're probably taking about something else.
Bank transfers are not free though and I don't get one-time use credit card numbers, mainly because my bank doesn't include a credit card to begin with, but services like Revolut are available here too (just maybe not very popular).
I do agree financial services are generally behind the times here, just maybe not in all the ways some may think.
Do you need to bring a passport or other documents to exchange currencies?
Though keep in mind that 3DS was also rolled out with a liability shift; banks sold it to merchants as "if you 3DS validate a transaction it's never fraudulent and the customer can't chargeback". Which is obviously untrue if you're using SMS 2FA, which can be defeated. Good thing most American merchants forget to turn on 3D Secure...
- Free or instant, pick one. FedNow was supposed to fix that but AFAIK it hasn't rolled out.
- Opening a bank account involves shittons of KYC paperwork. I've never had to prove residency though. In fact in Utah it's the opposite: you can prove residency (for a state ID card / drivers license) by, among other things, having a bank statement with your new address on it. No clue how that works with paperless.
- Virtual/one-time numbers are a thing but not widespread. Credit card companies sell services intended specifically to ensure getting a new number doesn't cancel recurring charges.
- 3DS (Three Domains Secure, not Nintendo 3DS) is technically supported but rarely enforced by merchants.
- Cashback is a gimmick used to justify payment fees.
I lived in a suburb city near Nagoya from end of 2022 to beginning of 2024. It's not Tokyo, but definitely not an "inaka" either. We got our Aeon Malls and even a Porsche dealer lol.
Edit: damn, there are many more Porsche center in Aichi than I thought there were. I'll keep this guess, though.
The main problem is that most services that accept a wire transfer might take a while to verify your bank transfer and will often not verify bank transfers outside business hours, so they're not quite as perfect as I would want them to be. If the bank systems could only have been upgraded to support including a reference number, or better yet provide a system for automatic verification by the submitter (such as a request link + verification link, tokens, QR code)... But I'm dreaming about change to some very old systems.
That said automaticly registered wire transfers aren't really used much lately in my experience. Mostly for stuff like salary, rent and big purchases like a car. Anything else that's automatic people just use cards for now. Precisely due to that lack of messaging/attribution.
For small daily person-to-person transfers, everyone I know uses PayPay since you just exchange phone numbers instead of more personal details. This is similar to back in Sweden where everyone uses Swish instead of regular wire transfers.
Changing the procedure is also a procedure, and is rarely done in disruptive ways.
That has been mimicked in electronic seals, I kid you not.
The licence fee isn't exactly a Japanese tradition, it was literally modeled after the BBC. There's even an anti-NHK political party
A local committee for upkeep of the neighborhood was also a thing in my parents neighborhood in Sweden, and the US has it even more formalized into HOAs
Edit: FYI, the NHK party changed its name for the 10th time and doesn't contain NHK in its name anymore.
Everyone’s old, and the local tech is very good at the things those people liked when they were young in the 70’s and 80’s.
Clearly there is lots of good engineering there but not for this new computer thing.
Obviously they can get rid of fax machines and Do Tech Better.
Here, go to a 7 floor electronics store and you'll see Walmart style greeters in larger numbers. Wall to wall. If you buy a washing machine you'll spend hours and meet a whole lot of uniformed employees to show you deference. Like the whole staff of that floor. You get to meet a village where everybody "loves" each other.
As if the store employees themselves cooperatively and humbly assembled the washing machine as a team effort. And no one person stands out.
An artisanal washing machine that crafts people diligently slaved away at making bespoke just for you. And sacred reams of paperwork they will equally fill out with the outmost of care and send by well trained hawk if need be. The more effort and "care" spent the better.
Or you can just order it online on the website for that very store. Same price. So what the hell?
I think it is because they don't view BS jobs as a bad thing but rather as necessary for an inclusive and harmonious society.
Theirs Not to Reason Why, Theirs But to Do and Die.
Receipt and delivery time is all that is necessary, 10 minutes tops, in and out. It absolutely can and should go that way and did in your case.
But sometimes the pomp and circumstance take over and you would think it is 1924 and these are the first machines sold in Japan or something. That's because on slow days that floor full of people have diddly squat to do. Count them, it is x4-5 more than elsewhere.
Next time you're in BIC stay a while and observe. Especially older couples, they love the attention. That's the other subtle aspect at play I think. Loneliness resents efficiency.
The Western solution seems to be to give people basic income and have them stay home. I offer no opinion on what is "better" and maybe I'm wrong but I really think that's what is going on.
Don't stay home, stay in uniform, we'll find you something <- not an entirely terrible way to be.
You do realize that Gen X literally grew up playing video games and with `Apple ][`s & `Apple //e` in every classroom right? You know Gen X led Web 1.0, right?
Hell, until very recently most non-combini ATM machines in Japan have limited business hours (like WTF do ATMs stop working on the weekends???), and buying online concert tickets means you buy it online, then go to the local 7/11 and print it out in paper form. The rest of the world has long since moved to E-sign and the average Japanese person is still expected to use a personal seal for business dealing.
It's like Japan took a very weird turn on their tech-tree in the late 80s and went off a deep end and invested all the points in toilets.
My toilet was smarter than Siri and could sing to me but god forbid if I wanted to pay my rent online lol.