But if I used a project, and that project's new owner hostilely relicensed parts of it, I'd assume that other parts are likely to go down the same path. I can understand why someone would want to make sure code developed under the previous social contract remains accessible and updated under the same terms.
You're also at the same risk if you choose to use their fork.
I use Emacs. If the FSF suddenly started pulling parts of it out, I would not sit there and hope that they didn't come after the bits I need. If someone forked it with strong assurances that I could keep using all of Emacs, I'd probably switch to that work. "Just fork the bits that get taken away" would not be an option I'd consider.
TLDR: They don't trust Redpanda to not pull the rug again later.
UPDATE: just watched the blobstream and realized there is exactly a repo called “redpanda-data/benthos” with the MIT components. Nice!
If you are committing to that then you should say so.
Finally, Redpanda did some partnerships with vendors nobody cares about whose businesses are at risk to show how you are opening up the ecosystem.
It actually comes off as somewhat malicious and Ashley's note where he notes he didn't read the article also comes off as not caring about developers (even insofar as he has facts wrong -- if the plug APIs remain compatible this creates more choice for users.)
If they'd instead chose to fork the plugins themselves (the only parts where the licenses changed, all except two are Apache V2) then all users can pick and choose which ones they include in their projects, and it doesn't fragment the ecosystem at all. Your plugins would compile in my project, and mine would compile in yours.
The part they're choosing to fork here, which will cause this rift in the community, is still MIT licensed: https://github.com/redpanda-data/benthos. If they simply chose to continue using this MIT part we can all live happily together in a utopian society fully saturated with plugged blobbery.
Edit: I'm bit a baby brained so I forgot that I'm literally streaming live in 30 minutes in order to explain all the changes in detail for those out of the loop: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8nVdUuWZ80