News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:27PM (#40537111)
The particulars of the case matter. Describing it as "hacking" is more than a bit misleading.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by JohnMakin on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:40PM (#40537261)
They were accessing a system via internal endpoints not released to the public. They were also using stolen credentials a former employee of songbird brought over to ticketmaster, and accessed devices using stolen credentials. If that isn't "hacking" then the word has lost all meaning.

https://www.justice.gov/usao-edny/pr/ticketmaster-pays-10-mi...

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:30PM (#40537956)
A former employee taking IP with them is usually considered to be IP theft more than hacking, and that's basically what happened.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by JohnMakin on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:04PM (#40538399)
Two things can be true at once - he stole credentials, and then used those credentials to gain unauthorized access to multiple systems (hacking).

As far as credentials being intellectual property, that doesn't sound quite right but I'm not an IP lawyer and it doesn't really matter.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:11PM (#40538485)
Let's put it this way: we wouldn't call it hacking if he had held on to his badge/keys to the building and got the information that way.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by JohnMakin on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:36PM (#40539349)
Let's put it this way - if he held on to his badge/keys to enter a building and used these credentials to access a computer system without authorization, then yes, it would be called hacking. The word hacking gets thrown around in dumb contexts sometimes, but this is perhaps the clearest use of the word "hacking" I can think of.

Like, what would make this hacking to you? The way an attacker gains credentials to access a system does not really matter. If he socially engineered these credentials, it'd still be hacking.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:51AM (#40543743)
Let's put it this way: before there were even laws against hacking, if you had a key you shouldn't have and you used to get into a building and steal some IP, if you were charged, it would be with trespass or breaking & entering, not hacking.

The term is appropriate, but it tends to evoke ideas of serious crimes, when hacking can be much more innocuous acts that often don't see much in the way of prosecution.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:48PM (#40538888)
> Let's put it this way: we wouldn't call it hacking if he had held on to his badge/keys to the building and got the information that way.

If he did that it'd be prosecutable as breaking and entering, and it's perfectly reasonable to use the term "hacking" as the digital counterpart for "breaking and entering".

EDIT: It also looks like you work at Ticketmaster, or at least used to? If that's the case, that's a rather weird thing not to mention in the context of this thread.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:02PM (#40539021)
To be clear: I agree it was hacking. I'm saying that aside from the IP theft angle, this kind of hacking doesn't usually get heavy handed consequences for individuals. AFAIK, the individual involved was not prosecuted criminally.

I used to work at Ticketmaster. I don't anymore and I didn't at the time of the incident, so it didn't seem relevant to the discussion.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by LikelyABurner on Friday May 31, 2024 @05:20PM (#40540380)
IANAL but this is textbook unauthorized access of a computer as has been drilled into me in every boring corporate training I do for my security work and thus is "hacking".

Telling the judge "but I wasn't wearing my black hoodie while listening to K-pop while doing it!" is going to be about as effective as telling the judge the legal code can't be trusted because it's not backed by a CI/CD system adhering to Agile practices. (Which a non-trivial number of Hacker News posters probably think would work.)

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:44PM (#40537300)
> The particulars of the case matter. Describing it as "hacking" is more than a bit misleading.

People have been prosecuted and convicted under the CFAA for significantly less.

The CFAA is a terribly abused law, but that is a fair use of the word "hacking".

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:32PM (#40537973)
If he'd kept a key or badge and got the information that way, no one would call it hacking.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:45PM (#40538129)
> If he'd kept a key or badge and got the information that way, no one would call it hacking.

No, they'd have called it breaking and entering. I don't know what point you think you're making.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:13PM (#40538509)
No, they'd have called it trespassing. That's the point I think I'm making.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @02:44PM (#40538847)
> No, they'd have called it trespassing. That's the point I think I'm making.

No, if someone retains a key to a location after their legal authorization to access the location has been rescinded, and then uses it to access that physical location, that is breaking and entering.

Regardless, "if they committed this crime with physical means instead of digitally, there would be a different criminal charge and a different word for it" is a point that is not particularly insightful, relevant, or interesting to discuss.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:03PM (#40539038)
Breaking and entering requires the use of force. Absent that, it is trespass.

The claim was that individuals suffer bigger consequences than people. The person involved was not fined $10 million. AFAIK, they were not prosecuted criminally.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:19PM (#40539187)
> Breaking and entering requires the use of force. Absent that, it is trespass.

No. This is right up there with "you can't report a person missing until it's been 24 hours" for most common popular legal misconceptions. It would be prosecutable as breaking and entering.

> The claim was that individuals suffer bigger consequences than people. The person involved was not fined $10 million. AFAIK, they were not prosecuted criminally.

Yeah, and that's not the comparison OP was making. If that's what you took away, read again, because you missed their point entirely.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:24PM (#40539250)
"Lol, if an individual does this, you're going to go to jail. A company does this? Tiny fine. What a world we live in."

An individual did do this. They did not go to jail.

Trespass vs. B&E is nuanced, and I'm definitely oversimplifying it. The "misconception" is widespread enough that it includes lawyers: https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/blog/breaking-entering-vs-tresp...

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by chimeracoder on Friday May 31, 2024 @04:19PM (#40539773)
> An individual did do this. They did not go to jail.

Right, and that's not the point OP was making.

> Trespass vs. B&E is nuanced, and I'm definitely oversimplifying it. The "misconception" is widespread enough that it includes lawyers

I'm guessing you didn't bother to read the link you dropped, because it actually undermines your entire claim. Before you pat yourself on the back, you might want to look up what qualifies as "use of force". It's not the way you seem to be using the word.

The only lens through which what you're saying is even vaguely correct is that some states don't have a specific statute of "breaking and entering", instead prosecuting it as "criminal trespass", but even then it's a distinction without a difference: it's prosecutable as a charge for using force to gain unauthorized access to a location with the express intent of committing a felony.

In any case, this whole discussion is pretty pointless, because as I already said, the fact that there's a different word used when the crime happens in meatspace vs. cyberspace is wholly uninteresting and not relevant to the original topic, and - as I also already said - you have clearly misunderstood the crux of OP's statement and so there's no point in continuing down this rabbithole.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:05AM (#40543800)
> I'm guessing you didn't bother to read the link you dropped, because it actually undermines your entire claim. Before you pat yourself on the back, you might want to look up what qualifies as "use of force". It's not the way you seem to be using the word. >

That's a good guess, but wrong.

> The only lens through which what you're saying is even vaguely correct is that some states don't have a specific statute of "breaking and entering", instead prosecuting it as "criminal trespass", but even then it's a distinction without a difference: it's prosecutable as a charge for using force to gain unauthorized access to a location with the express intent of committing a felony.

I mentioned that trespass vs. B&E is nuanced, and that I was definitely oversimplifying it. If someone was curious they might have investigated this matter for the relevant jurisdiction. They might even have some familiarity with the case. But that would indeed require more curiosity than someone who doesn't even read a link before they drop it.

> In any case, this whole discussion is pretty pointless, because as I already said, the fact that there's a different word used when the crime happens in meatspace vs. cyberspace is wholly uninteresting and not relevant to the original topic, and - as I also already said - you have clearly misunderstood the crux of OP's statement and so there's no point in continuing down this rabbithole.

Or maybe I just wasn't doing a good job of being clear on the point. There was both an individual and a corporation at fault in that specific case, so you don't have to speculate as to which party was more severely punished. The OP's assertion is flat wrong.

Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by finack on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:43PM (#40537296)
No they don't. Rules for companies and individuals are different in this country, unless you possess some secret to getting away with potentially ruining the lives of 1.5 times the population of the United States with the financial equivalent of a slap on the wrist.
Re:Data allegedly stolen from 560M Ticketmaster users by cbsmith on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:31PM (#40537968)
That hack impacted 1.5 times the population of the United States? I think you're conflating events.