News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by brudgers on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:20AM (#4052734)
I'll admit it. I'm as skeptical of this as I am of religious claims.

'"Our findings are statistically consistent with a head-on collision between the Andromeda galaxy and our Milky Way galaxy," adds Roeland van der Marel of the STScI.'

How the hell does one establish statistical consistency when predicting an event four billion years in the future across 2.5 million light years? The sample size which has been analyzed is zero.

"The Hubble Space Telescope team, led by van der Marel, conducted extraordinarily precise observations of the sideways motion of M31 that remove any doubt that it is destined to collide and merge with the Milky Way."

Here is the fundamental fallacy at heart of the matter - the very one which makes this certainty bad science: the degree of precision with which one makes their measurements has absolutely no bearing on the accuracy of those measurements. Instead it indicates that all the errors were repeatable.

Science does some wonderful things...when it uses its own original methods rather than relying on faith that its high purpose makes its conclusions true.

Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by bfe on Friday June 01, 2012 @09:57AM (#4053352)
At its heart, this is straightforward mechanics using precision measurements of the tangential motion of a statistically large sample of bright stars in Andromeda, as opposed to trying to track every single star in Andromeda (impossible of course), combined with radial motion easily measured by the Doppler shift on spectral lines. We know how to do this.

There are three separate papers that have been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal but haven't appeared yet. Let's see what they say.

Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by brudgers on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:21PM (#4055858)
>"There are three separate papers that have been accepted for publication in The Astrophysical Journal but haven't appeared yet. Let's see what they say."

The metaphysical equivalent of an Encyclical. Swapping one group of experts for a group of experts with different training doesn't get one anything without the premise that the new experts espouse the one true view.

Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by oscilloscope on Friday June 01, 2012 @08:32AM (#4053037)
You're right to be skeptical, but this isn't a religious claim. It's the best prediction these scientists came up with based on current theories of relativity/cosmology and measurements from Hubble.

This is the best science can do when experimentation is impossible: apply theories to measurements.

Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by brudgers on Friday June 01, 2012 @09:43AM (#4053298)
The hypothesis is no more verifiable than a claim that our actions in this life determine our circumstances in the next one. Indeed, I have better evidence for an hypothesis regarding karma right here on HN.
Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by drcube on Friday June 01, 2012 @09:50AM (#4053323)
Do you rely on faith when you expect the next full moon according to your calendar? What about your belief that the sun will come up tomorrow?

Most of our science is done without the benefit of a laboratory at all. Historical sciences (paleontology, geology, etc) and cosmology have to rely on other methods. It doesn't make them based on faith.

Re:NASA can now predict Andromeda collision with certainty by brudgers on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:21PM (#4055537)
The number of observed full moons is significantly greater than zero. In addition any prediction of the next full moon is verifiable within a few days. Finally, observations of the full moon do not depend on access to equipment not accessible to the general public.

In other words, in regards to the full moon I am not required to place my trust in others based upon their ritualistic training or privileged access to an unseen world.