Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by threeseed on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:04PM
(#40516362)
Parody is considered fair use because the public knows that it isn't the celebrity.
This isn't the case here.
If you want analogies it's like creating a Ferrari body, putting it around a cheap car and trying to sell it.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by kaibee on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:38PM
(#40516757)
> If you want analogies it's like creating a Ferrari body, putting it around a cheap car and trying to sell it.
A proud tradition?
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by CRConrad on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:33PM
(#40517859)
Eh, what? No, not at all. That was, if anything, the other way around.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by bryanlarsen on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:04PM
(#40516359)
That's fair use. Fair use is limited to commentary, search engines, criticism, parody, news reporting, research, and scholarship.
OpenAI will try and claim fair use, but I don't think they'll succeed.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by sandworm101 on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:08PM
(#40516405)
Fair use only applies to copyrighted material. A voice, a mode of speech, is not copyrightable. Step one in a copyright defense it to prove that no "taking" occurred, or that any involved material wasn't protected by copyright (Lohan v. GTA). Only then do you get to affirmative defenses such as fair use (Hustler). This case would not get that far, not absent evidence of literal copies of her recorded voice being played back by the software.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court
by freejazz on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @03:59PM
(#40516300)
Is literal copying a necessary element for a right of publicity claim? I don't think so, but I don't litigate them. I would think that OpenAI's conduct in referencing ScarJo and her body of work in relation to the voice would allow for a reasonable inference that they intended the public to believe it was ScarJo's voice, and not that of a similarly sounding voice actor?
from the article: "It doesn’t matter whether a person’s actual voice is used in an imitation or not, Rothman says, only whether that audio confuses listeners"
Do you have non-layman knowledge about these kinds of claims?
And pity every other upcoming actor who looks/sounds vaguely similar to an existing famous person. Shall they be gagged, the very sound of their voice owned by someone else?