News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by cladopa on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:54AM (#40510938)
What happens is that Chinese prices are not real because batteries and EV are subsidised by the Chinese Government. Also Chinese market is full of restrictions for foreign companies.
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by tromp on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @08:16AM (#40511120)
Many countries subsidize EVs in the form of tax credits for people buying them, and some by giving very favorable loans to EV manufacturers.
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by resolutebat on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:59AM (#40510989)
Sigh, this old trope again. The Chinese government stopped subsidizing EV purchases in 2022. There are some tax breaks, but they're also getting phased out. Neither is or was ever all that different from the various EV subsidies found in most Western countries.

https://dialogue.earth/en/business/life-after-subsidies-for-...

Doing business in China is indeed very hard, but Tesla is still selling quite well there, despite absolutely furious competition.

Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by cladopa on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @08:11AM (#40511078)
It does not need to be EV purchases. When the company I worked for went to China, it paid 0% taxes for several years. This is a subsidy. I worked there, and everything was subsidised, the steel and aluminium plants for example. If as engineer you don't pay taxes on your salary, you are subsidised.
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by tooltalk on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:22PM (#40518305)
China's EV subsidies have existed in various shapes and forms since 2009 -- renewed, extended every 3-4 years. The last "direct purchase" subsidies ended on Jan 1, 2023; it was however extended as a "tax credit" in June 2023 for another 4 years with $72+B budget. This is also in the same article you cited (see translated below):

  Extension of the preferential tax policy for car purchases The total reduction and exemption is expected to reach 520 billion yuan —— Precision to provide assistance to the expansion of new energy vehicles 2023-06-21

  The Ministry of Finance, the General Administration of Taxation, and the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology recently issued a joint announcement to clearly continue and optimize the tax reduction and exemption policy for the purchase of new energy vehicles to support the development of the new energy automobile industry and promote automobile consumption. According to preliminary estimates, through the implementation of the extension policy, the total scale of vehicle purchase tax relief from 2024 to 2027 will reach 520 billion yuan.
Now, in addition to this, there also various industry subsidies, export credit/refund/rebates, and other financial instruments by gov't that are difficult to account for (because they are not public info).
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by pjc50 on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @08:37AM (#40511291)
If China wants to subsidize the US renewables transition, why shouldn't we let them pay for it? Isn't that draining funds from the Chinese government directly?
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by tooltalk on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:06PM (#40518169)
It's called predatory pricing -- you buy cheap now, pay later when they come to recoup their cost. It won't drain their bank if they end up undercutting/destroying all local competitor and we become dependent on them.

This is not necessarily a problem if we can all peacefully coexist. China has a history of weaponizing their dominant market position to settle geopolitical/market disputes -- eg, rare earth metal ban against Japan in 2010; China's recent graphite "export control" to protect Chinese EV companies' business in markets abroad.

The fact that China practically banned all foreign EV battery makers from local EV market and forced EV OEMs to use locally made batteries by local battery makers to dominate the global battery market since 2016 under Xi's Make-In-China 2025 adds to the view that this isn't purely about saving the planet or making affordable EVs for the rest of us.

Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by pjc50 on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:56AM (#40521557)
Their "made in China" policy is Bad while our "made in America" policy is Good?
Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by tooltalk on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:54AM (#40521891)
No, I think they are about equal.

The US already has been countering China's every anticompetitive, discriminatory policy measure by more or less equal response: for instance, eliminating all subsidies on EVs with critical minerals sourced from non-free trading nations and banning Chinese EV/battery companies, and so on -- or otherwise known as Biden's IRA (vs Xi's Made-In-China 2025).

I'm not necessarily taking sides, but if you feel that the US's policy is bad, that's probably because China's original policy was also bad. If you were ok with China's exclusionary EV policy since 2016, you probably shouldn't be crying about the US's policy today since it's designed to mirror China's.

Do note however that, in March, China did file a WTO complaint accusing the US (IRA) of doing what China has been doing past decade under MIC 2025 -- misusing subsidies to force local content, local production (aka, in international trade lingo, it's called "local/domestic content requirement"). So I'm a bit troubled by China's double-standard.

Re:New BYD Hybrid Can Drive Non-Stop for More Than 2k Kilome... by asadotzler on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:22AM (#40523391)
The US and California have given Tesla about three times what China has given BYD. And the US doesn't have restrictions on Chinese companies?

Do some research before spewing this kind of nonsense.