News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why We're Turning Psychiatric Labels into Identities by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @11:23AM (#40501627)
I’m not aware of this scoreboard

Please provide a link or otherwise reference to this scoreboard

Unless you were writing metaphorically in which case you’ll need to write a lot more to describe it

Re:Why We're Turning Psychiatric Labels into Identities by snapcaster on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @12:23PM (#40502437)
Sorry thought it was clear but maybe a little poorly phrased. My point is: the number of meaningful solutions to problems by practitioners is infinity. The number of meaningful solutions to problems by non-practicing philosophers is zero as far as I know. Open to it being non-zero, but don't think the score is remotely close

edit: I think often theoreticians are unable to appreciate the constraints or nuance of actually "doing it" so frequently their "solutions" don't survive impact with reality

Re:Why We're Turning Psychiatric Labels into Identities by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:55PM (#40504175)
Can you differentiate between implementation quality of a tool?

The “platonic wheel” is not a concern for someone trying to make money selling tires - but nor do those tires by being a function of successful commerce describe a “platonic wheel”

Perhaps the platonic wheel is in some intersectional saddle point between theory and practice but to say that only that which is commonly adopted has measure ignores the philosophical genesis that precedes and impregnates the production process.