News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Case for Facebook by greenyoda on Thursday May 31, 2012 @02:46PM (#4049669)
I don't buy the article's claim that Facebook is a "natural monopoly". A natural monopoly would be something like an electric utility, which would be very hard to compete with since you'd have to build out a very expensive alternate network of power lines before you could even start selling.

So let's look at what business Facebook is in and whether they have a monopoly in that market. Facebook is not in the business of running a social network -- most of their revenue comes from selling ads. Their customers are advertisers, not their users. Their competitor is not really the puny Google Plus, it's the mighty Google AdWords. And Google is currently beating them in that market, so no monopoly there.

Number of minutes spent on the site per month is the wrong metric to measure Facebook's success by. What really matters in both Facebook's and Google's business models is ad revenue per dollar spent on operations.

Re:The Case for Facebook by saraid216 on Thursday May 31, 2012 @03:50PM (#4049991)
(Disclaimer: I first found out about the concept of natural monopoly in this article, so when I say I am not an expert, I mean I have no clue whatsoever.)

Well, a natural monopoly doesn't mean that it is a monopoly, right? Just that it's most efficient as a monopoly. It's not impossible to build out an alternate network of power lines; it's just prohibitively difficult. Maybe it'd be more correct to say that it's Facebook's specific targeting mechanism of ad delivery that it has a monopoly on?

For instance, I imagine a cellular network is a natural monopoly by the exact same reasoning you say that an electric utility is one. Except... neither Verizon nor AT&T nor whatever actually has such thorough market domination: in fact, their competition is partly on the very pervasiveness of that network.