Better to say that "present-day publishers work hard to make the cover something you can sell a book by."
> so a) I created a mailing list, you should probably sign up and a) I would like to explain why your business should probably send more email than it is right now.
You probably meant "a) ... b) ..."
BTW, am I the only one who feels like this is just a squeeze page?
Of course we do. At least for a first cut judgment - after all the cover has the book's title, author, and usually a blurb; that is usually enough information to either discard it or decide to take a closer look.
For instance, compare
"The Planet Wizard" http://www.goodshowsir.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/Plan...
to
"Taken By You" http://img1.fantasticfiction.co.uk/images/n16/n82162.jpg
The actual maxim should be "Judging a book by its cover actually has an extremely high success rate and can be safely done in many cases, however it has a finite failure rate especially in terms of determining the quality of a book and so should be avoided in cases where incorrect judgement will cause problems".
PS. Yes, I know those examples were entirely unnecessary, I just wanted to take the opportunity to show off some amusingly terrible book covers.
Sometimes I even judge an entire store-ful of books without looking at 'em. I've already judged the entire contents of my local "Anarchist Bookstore" without setting foot inside the place.
There's thousands of bookstores in China that I've never even seen, and I know I won't enjoy the books inside them. Look at me, I'm dismissing billions of books that I have never seen and will never see, simply because I suspect they're probably written in languages I don't understand!
Anyway, if I ever get to the point where I'm judging a book by actually looking at its cover then that book is already getting way more scrutiny from me than most.
Which leads back to the original point.
Most of us are not in the business of selling anonymous writing written by people of no particular expertise which is designed to have a shelf-life of twenty minutes and yet we spend extraordinarily amounts of time producing things in a cover which says exactly that. We should, instead, devote more of our limited resources to creating work in the cover that says "important things you should act upon immediately from the people you trust more than anyone in the world about this topic."
I think the real problem you're trying to address is the lack of confidence of programmers into their own writings; their bullshit detector is too sensitive when placed too close to the source.
But isn't the phrase "You shouldn't judge a book by its cover"? (And even when "can't" is used, what's meant is often "shouldn't").
Of course people judge books by their cover; they also judge people by the clothes they wear, their height or skin color. Should they?
It depends. Prejudice is our own little Bayesian filtering; it works sometimes but it's not "pure": it tends to have a strong effect on reality (for example, CEOs are mostly of above-average height: not because being tall makes you a good CEO but because we expect tall people to be leaders).
> 99% of geeks will report never having buying anything as a result of an email
bought (just to show that I read at least this far!)