Re:A Defense of Philosophy (against Paul Graham)
by agentcoops on Saturday December 20, 2008 @10:12PM
(#405120)
While I agree that slogging through Aristotle and Kant is incredibly painful (and many departments definitely over-emphasis), I think it's undeniably useful for one pursuing a career or even hobby in philosophy to have some knowledge of the discipline's history. If nothing else, it demonstrates exactly what not to do and how vital clarity and a rigorous, logical methodology are.
Re:A Defense of Philosophy (against Paul Graham)
by GavinB on Saturday December 20, 2008 @10:55PM
(#405158)
I just think that a succinct summary of their views by a clear modern writer would have been sufficient for my purposes. For others who are more interested, it's great to have.
Re:A Defense of Philosophy (against Paul Graham)
by andreasvc on Monday December 22, 2008 @05:10PM
(#406947)
The problem with this idea is that the jury is still out on the interpretation of a lot of ancient texts. Anyone summarizing them will either put their own spin on them or will tediously have to expound on all the possible interpretations.
It's very frustrating to be told to write in a concise style and then asked to read some really obfuscated nonsense.