News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by rlpb on Thursday May 31, 2012 @10:26AM (#4048148)
"Of all the mathematical sciences, computer science is unquestionably the dullest."

Really? I find it the most interesting. Which is, I think, what led me here.

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by alecbenzer on Thursday May 31, 2012 @10:31AM (#4048176)
Sigh.

I keeping seeing all these cs vs programming articles. I'm really waiting for a "fuck just programming, cs is fucking awesome" one, because all the ones I've read so far sound like "haha, stupid math nerds and their cs. just learn to program" (a bit of mis-characterization of this article, maybe, but I get annoyed when people say something I like is "unquestionably" dull)

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by RegEx on Thursday May 31, 2012 @10:44AM (#4048244)
Knowing HN, someone will surely deliver, and the front page will have 4-6 variants of "Why you should/shouldn't learn computer science"
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by alecbenzer on Thursday May 31, 2012 @10:51AM (#4048280)
After I wrote out "fuck just programming, cs is fucking awesome", I immediately thought it sounded like a good name for a blog post :)

Is my hipster showing?

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday May 31, 2012 @12:41PM (#4048905)
I've been mentally composing a blog post entitled, "Programming is hard, which is why I don't want to do it" about the differences between "real programming" and computer science. The thesis is that "real programming" involves solving problems that are inherently simple but have loads of incidental state and details to mentally keep track of, whereas computer science involves solving streamlined, semi-pure instances of inherently hard problems.

I prefer computer-science because I don't like loading five windows and 18 tabs worth of incidental state into my working mind just to get any work done at all, but I greatly enjoy cutting away every impurity and irrelevant detail to forge a creative solution from the ore of a truly difficult problem.

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by lookACamel on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:39AM (#4052541)
Please write this blog post out in full because it sounds exactly like what I've always felt but haven't been able to express properly.
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by eli_gottlieb on Sunday June 03, 2012 @04:54PM (#4061721)
Done and submitted to HN.
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by lookACamel on Wednesday June 06, 2012 @09:48PM (#4077175)
Thanks. I really think the difference you've pointed out is something more people should discuss, instead of implying that CS is just like programming(coding) but with more math.

Instead most people focus on how programming isn't CS enough, or how CS isn't real-world enough and they miss or gloss over the fundamental difference between the two in regard to the type of cognitive abilities required.

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by RegEx on Thursday May 31, 2012 @11:05AM (#4048356)
Yes. Unfortunately, I have only but one fuck to give, so I find your title a bit overwhelming ;)
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by 27182818284 on Thursday May 31, 2012 @11:04AM (#4048353)
Maybe its my physics background, but I've always found the problem to be a lack of analogues.

We have physics, but we also have mechanical and civil engineering. Likewise we should have a computer science major and a developer major. Just as how mechanical and civil engineers still take some physics and math courses, the developers will take some of the CS courses in addition to specialized courses for their major.

Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by allenp on Thursday May 31, 2012 @11:15AM (#4048422)
Perhaps this is the thinking behind many of the Software Engineering degrees? They typically focus on requirements gathering, architecture, process, and business integration with less focus on the nitty gritty of sorting algorithms or how compilers work.
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by krakensden on Thursday May 31, 2012 @11:28AM (#4048507)
We used to get those, or at least articles that were like LOOK WHAT YOU CAN DO WITH THIS THEOREM.
Re:Let's Not Call It "Computer Science" If We Really Mean "C... by jzukoff on Thursday May 31, 2012 @10:35AM (#4048202)
was tempted to stop reading when I got here. Computer Science is fascinating...and an incredibly broad field. The notion that the author could make the sweeping accusation that it is "unquestionably the dullest" of the mathematical sciences leads me to disregard his opinions in general.