Re:Apple's M4 Has Reportedly Adopted the ARMv9 Architecture
by skavi on Friday May 24, 2024 @07:20PM
(#40471339)
It’s been a while since I looked, but I remember SVE2 being much more usable than SVE. A64FX was SVE IIRC. I think SVE did not do a great job of fully replacing NEON.
Re:Apple's M4 Has Reportedly Adopted the ARMv9 Architecture
by janwas on Saturday May 25, 2024 @07:34AM
(#40474262)
Fair point about movprfx, I understand they were short on encoding space. This can be mitigated by using *_x versions of intrinsics where masks are not used.
The sizeless headache is anyway there if you want to support RISC-V V, which we do.
One other data point in favor of SVE: its backend in Highway is only 6KLOC vs NEON's 10K, with a similar ratio of #if (indicating less fragmentation, more orthogonal).
simdjson specifically benefitted from Intel's hardware decision to implement a 512b permute from 2x 512b registers with a throughput of 1/cycle. That's area-expensive, which is (probably) why ARM has historically skimped on tbl performance, only changing as of the Cortex-X4.
Anyway simdjson is an argument for 256b/512b vector permute, not 128b SVE.
Having written a lot of NEON and investigated SVE... I disagree that SVE is a nicer ISA. The set of what's 2-operand destructive, what instructions have maskable forms vs. needing movprfx that's only fused on A64FX, and dealing the intrinsics issues that come from sizeless types are all unneeded headaches. Plus I prefer NEON's variable shift to SVE's variable shifts.