News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building an AI game studio: what we've learned so far by johnnyanmac on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @07:51PM (#40435706)
>AI doesn't eliminate the complexity, it just hides it. At best it'll get you maybe 80% of where you want to go and you can get to the remaining 20% by hand. At worst, the complexity is so thoroughly hidden that addressing it isn't an option. It simply does not allow you to manually edit the outputs, or makes it unreasonably difficult to do so.

That's the thing about games. It's "easy" to make a website, it's very hard to make a not buggy, minimally compelling game. And it works with multiple medium to boot.

If an AI can get me 80% of the way to a good UI, or a decent asset, or a right sounding SFX, that's a huge boon to development. The big issue with these early adopters tend to be that they

1. lack the ability to finish that 20% of editing, because that 20% is still really dang hard.

2. aren't interested in finishing the 20% because that 80% will be enough of a cash grab for asset flip level studios. Hence how the reputation of tech becomes a grift rather than a boon.

3. can do it, but want to be first to market so they skimp out and get something out for financial reasons

These all work against what consumers want out of their game, but that's early tech for you.

Re:Building an AI game studio: what we've learned so far by kjkjadksj on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @12:26PM (#40442824)
You are comparing an apple to an apple pie. The “easy” website is going to be something that looks like static html. The “easy” game will look similarly low tech: maybe a platformer that looks like it was written for an atari. 3d modern games are not the only way to make games although thats been a popular way for some time.
Re:Building an AI game studio: what we've learned so far by johnnyanmac on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @03:42PM (#40445404)
I can clarify. an "easy" website can still do its job and get you traction, because the website design and architecture is not going to affect your product as long as you follow the simple rules. The website is not your primary product, it is an ad to your actual product.

There are a few outliers like Vampire Survivors, but for the most part a simple game will not penetrate this market, and it is the product you're selling. Unless you're going to try to be like that dev that makes a simple game every month, for years on end, you're probably won't succeed making "simple" games alone (even then, you can argue that the primary audience is not a traditional gamer by that point).