Re:A transport protocol's view of Starlink
by inemesitaffia on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @04:26AM
(#40438654)
It's not unusual to see occasionally missing routers in a traceroute, please.
You be capping
You be capping
That’s meaningless. Control planes are often policed sure, but on overload will simply drop. In my experience they drop icmp to expired before echo response but most will generate ttl expired just fine.
Any router capable of processing a full bgp table, and to be honest any router made in the last 20 years, is perfectly capable of responding to icmp echos.
There was then a second argument that “3rd world” routers aren’t as good as ones in western country. In the majority of cases they’re exactly the same. That western arrogance is somewhere between insulting and amusing.
The final argument is about path loss/jitter/etc, specially loss on the first hop (your “my crappy 3G provider” argument)
That’s exactly what this test of starlink is showing.
Starlink is a great tool in specific cases, but the fanboyish ness often drowns out the actual benefits.