News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RISC vs. CISC by John R. Mashey (1995) by sapiogram on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:08PM (#40409049)
What's RISC about adding more registers?
Re:RISC vs. CISC by John R. Mashey (1995) by ajross on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:26PM (#40409165)
The simple answer is that a big symmetric register set has always been a hallmark of RISC ISAs, because having lots of symmetric registers increases throughput by reducing compiler-generated spill/fill overhead and permits more permissive ABIs for leaf functions that need the extra space.

The complicated answer is that, no, it's not especially "reduced" and you could implement all those other RISCy ideas in a much smaller set of GPRs without otherwise effecting the "RISCiness" of the design. But that answer is a little specious, since it's true of all the other RISCy traits too. Most of them stand alone, which is why the whole debate tends to be a little silly.

Re:RISC vs. CISC by John R. Mashey (1995) by Symmetry on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:29AM (#40414020)
The name "RISC" is something we gave to a particular design philosophy, but not everything in that philosophy is summed up in the name. Classic RISC designs have 32 registers to make up for the lack of instructions that operate directly on memory addresses and to make things easier for the compiler and achieve good performance without load-op-store instructions.