News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:06AM (#40405753)
A philosophical framework in which creating an artificial entity that is conscious and self-aware in a human-like manner is as straightforward as modeling the human brain is monistic materialism.

Of course, it’s not the only framework available. Among the modern takes, Donald Hoffman’s interface theory of perception (explored in, say, his Objects of Consciousness paper[0]) is an interesting one that appears to align with monistic idealism, for example.

Being wrong about this is generally not that impactful, until it concerns policies around ML. Adopting the former means we may have conscious software, which presumably should be granted human rights. However, if we hold the latter, manufacturing a “true” artificial consciousness may be unachievable using the means we employ (it might be just a philosophical zombie).

[0] I don’t personally endorse the paper or his views, but they can be an acceptable starting point for a technical person interested in exploring monistic idealism: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10....

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by smokel on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:39AM (#40406232)
> we may have conscious software, which presumably should be granted human rights

A dog (most likely) has consciousness, but no human rights.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by tomhoward on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:54AM (#40406310)
It has animal rights, which are broadly commensurate with the level of consciousness and agency it’s deemed to have.

Mammals and other animals have legal protections not afforded to fish and insects.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by mc32 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:06AM (#40406378)
In some countries… some countries hardly observe basic human rights much less any animal rights. Some have none on the books.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by tomhoward on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:13AM (#40406402)
Sure but this is nitpicking, as is your GP comment, and neither refute the point that the original commenter was making: modern/advanced societies have laws to protect conscience beings from exploitation and cruelty.

(As I was writing the comment I thought “ugh will someone chime in and point out that not all countries have strong animal protection laws? Do I really need to preempt that in my comment?”)

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by smokel on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:41AM (#40406570)
I was not nitpicking, but I could have spent more time on my reply.

What I was hinting at is that it is not simply consciousness that gets us these laws. Laws have been around for a long time, and have many different reasons for existing and persisting to exist. The most rational reason for laws is probably that it helps us to thrive as a species.

IMHO laws do not easily extend to animals or other organisms, let alone AI systems. What is the use of animal rights laws if you can simply get killed to be eaten (cows, pigs), or if you are considered a nuisance (bugs). What would be the reason to provide AIs with protection laws if they have no memory, no emotion, and no pain?

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by bugglebeetle on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:06AM (#40406693)
>Modern/advanced societies have laws to protect conscious beings from exploitation and cruelty.

I can think of no such society where this is generally true. One need only consider that pigs are far smarter than dogs and then the median pig’s life in said societies.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by tomhoward on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:31AM (#40406844)
Laws exist that ban practices that are - according to those who set and enforce the laws - excessively cruel to pigs. That’s all this discussion is about.

That pigs are still treated with cruelty is a terrible thing, and I’d happily see more done to protect all animals against cruelty. But it’s a separate argument to what’s relevant here.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by bugglebeetle on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:32PM (#40409209)
No, unfortunately, this is goalpost shifting. We’ve gone from “cruelty” to “excessive cruelty,” nor are there any laws that prevent the common sense understanding of either thing from happening to the median pig. One can here also point out that we in fact engage in such extreme cruelty that they have to make it illegal to document it:

https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/1/11/18176551/ag-gag...

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by DeathArrow on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:20AM (#40406450)
But does a bug have consciousness? What about a bacteria?
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by smokel on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:45AM (#40406592)
I suppose the bug has, but the bacteria doesn't. I'd assume that some kind of memory is required for consciousness.

I'd even go so far to say that consciousness is nothing more than having a memory of the state you were in.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by TaupeRanger on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:58AM (#40406656)
Bacteria cells absolutely have types of memory. And by your definition a Python program written by any random undergrad in CS 101 has consciousness.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by smokel on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:10AM (#40406722)
In order for my definition to make sense, the organism or program must be able to observe the memory of the state. In the case of the bacteria and the Python program, I doubt they are able to do that in any meaningful way.

But I would not mind if a slightly more involved program, or a system of plants for that matter, would be considered conscious. The basic definition seems fairly irrelevant, and it obviously matters how much the specific type of consciousness matches our own experience for us humans to actually care.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by TaupeRanger on Sunday May 19, 2024 @11:33AM (#40407584)
Just handwavy nonsense. What counts as “observing”? Obviously the bacterial system will “observe” the memory when using it determine current behavior. If the basic definition is irrelevant, why did you post a comment outlining a claim of what consciousness is “nothing more than”? This is silly and not worth further engagement.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by smokel on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:58PM (#40408990)
Note that I tried to counter the idea that an AI should presumably get human rights. In that context, I think a definition of consciousness is irrelevant.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Sunday May 19, 2024 @09:40AM (#40406899)
If a chatbot obtained from an emulation of a human brain behaves in a human-like manner, and is attributed consciousness and self-awareness, good luck arguing that its consciousness is like that of a dog.

…and even if you succeed, abusing a dog in the way we abuse ML-based products would not be acceptable in any developed country.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by chr1 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @01:32PM (#40408385)
If we abuse a dog we have no way to restore it to its previous state. With computer programs we have a perfect time machine, so any thing that one may call "horrible" can be done and then undone without any moral consequences.

This btw also is the answer to the question of evil in religion, god can do whatever he wants without being evil, because it is effectively all in his imagination, and for the people living in our computers we'll be gods.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @03:14AM (#40425118)
There are many leaps here, but the biggest leap is how reverting abuse later nullifies suffering incurred.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by chr1 on Monday May 27, 2024 @06:37PM (#40495443)
Because the sufferer is back exactly at the state before suffering, without even a recollection of suffering. And all the suffering was merely number multiplication.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:00PM (#40601132)
This belief is very, very far from mainstream. It implies that suffering is a complete non-issue in general—after all, we all die and at that point by definition don’t have a recollection of prior suffering (or anything, really).

Since “resetting” is equivalent to killing a being and creating a new being in its place, saying it nullifies all suffering already incurred can take you on a very dangerous path.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by thriftwy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @10:10AM (#40407089)
> creating an artificial entity that is conscious and self-aware in a human-like manner is as straightforward as modeling the human brain is monistic materialism.

Why then, not modelling such ebtity isn't creating a self-aware entity? After all, the outcome of a computation does not depend on whether it is actually done.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Sunday May 19, 2024 @11:07AM (#40407422)
There are computations, the outcomes of which are unknown unknown until actually done.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by thriftwy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @12:07PM (#40407825)
What changes when they are known? I believr it affects yout consciousness, not the one being simulated. The latter does not have "I'm being actually simulated" input
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Sunday May 19, 2024 @12:22PM (#40407954)
"Actually simulated" is such an oxymoron. So which is it? Is the consciousness actual, simulated, or actually simulated? And does the resulting state of mind change the universe, or merely reveal its hidden structure?

It's easy to get lost in these unsolvable paradoxes when you try reducing all of creation down to logic. Problem is, logic is not all of creation.

Consciousness requires a soul. Otherwise you're confused stardust sans mission.

A computer is just a calculator. You might as well ask if {addition, subtraction, multiplication, division} is God.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by Scarblac on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:06PM (#40409039)
> Consciousness requires a soul

What's a soul? How can you possibly know that's what's required?

Maybe it requires a blerpqu.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by User23 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:56PM (#40411029)
The soul is the animating principle. The Latin for soul, anima, is where we get our words animal, (in)animate, and so on.

In the most loose sense the soul is whatever it is that a living thing stops having when it becomes a dead thing.

Philosophically speaking saying “consciousness requires a soul” is a consequence of the observation that consciousness requires not being dead.

People, many of whom were assuredly considerably more intelligent than you or me, have spent thousands of years pondering what exactly the nature of souls is. Your metasyntactic zinger adds exactly nothing to that ongoing dialog. But by definition we know souls exist, at least as much as any abstract principle does and perhaps more than some.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by Thiez on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:03AM (#40413036)
So then bacteria have souls? And computers will never have one since they're not biological. But also there doesn't seem to be a relationship between souls and consciousness, so they are irrelevant.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by binkethy on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:39AM (#40413204)
I will argue that a self reproduced organism that has organized its own self reproduction over the course of N generations and which metabolizes what inputs it can, defining a niche in the complex web of life != an attempt by one organism to call its tools independent consciousnesses
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by User23 on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:39AM (#40415999)
> So then bacteria have souls?

Yes.

Plants, fungi, and everything else that's alive also have souls. In fact the term medical "vegetative state" is using Aristotelian vocabulary. Obviously it's not saying the patient has acquired chloroplasts.

> And computers will never have one since they're not biological.

That depends. Can a computing device come alive? Inanimate matter evidently somehow came alive at least once so I don't see how we can rule it out.

> But also there doesn't seem to be a relationship between souls and consciousness, so they are irrelevant.

So far as I know everything that we've verified to have consciousness is alive and thus has a soul. I'm very interested in any counter-examples if you have any to offer though.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by _a_a_a_ on Sunday May 19, 2024 @01:48PM (#40408489)
> Consciousness requires a soul

Any actual evidence for this is welcome.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 20, 2024 @07:59AM (#40414502)
I'm glad to discuss it, but that's all the evidence you're ever going to get, if you personally have not experienced... it. Through meditation, psychedelia, or religious practice. First-hand witness accounts and historical records are your evidence. How long you ignore it all is up to you.

Once upon a time I was locked in a mind prison of material logic. I considered myself transhuman, dreamed of cybernetics and the singularity. Thought that all religious peoples are idiots stuck in ancient fairy tales. Then I experienced a sequence of odd coincidences and inexplicable situations where spiritual entities guided me, causing a complete deconstruction of my entire worldview.

Now it's obvious to me the truth I had been so vehemently running away from my whole life, and the propaganda, indoctrination, and brainwashing are laid bare before me to see. The modern "we don't need no God" ideology is literally terminally ill. Everyone who blindly follows science and government are being consumed by them. Fertility is falling off a cliff. They're all mentally ill and medicated. Mandatory medical genetic experiments and engineered bioweapon plagues are murdering its followers and the fact that this ongoing debacle is being actively suppressed in media and politics tells me clear as day, the devil himself has taken root and hold of this world.

Meanwhile, in the churches I frequent, I see happy families practically building paradise on Earth, the kind I got to see as a child, and I know most people are headed to the same hell I climbed out of, like zombies. No amount of talking with these self-destructive delusionists will convince them to even try praying once in their lives, even as a joke.

I have all the evidence I need; My life has made a miraculous turnaround from spiritual guidance. If you'd like, I can ask the spirits to guide you through me.

The main thing to know about the spirit world is this: Good spirits require your explicit permission to come aboard and help you. The bad ones invite themselves in and destroy you from within. That's why humans are fundamentally religious creatures, and you ignore the spirit world at your own peril.

It's like the microbiome in your body. You gotta let good/neutral bacteria make a home of you, lest the bad ones take residence and literally kill you from within. And it's not "you fall dead the moment you stop believing", it's "these hostile bacteria literally control your mind to cause unhealthy behavior for their benefit", like overeating sugar (obesity very prevalent), being selfish, greedy, etc.

A prayer a day keeps the evil spirits away. This is not a matter of faith for me, it's the truth I've experienced for myself, and the evidence for which I see written in our very civilizational DNA. You just choose to ignore the evidence because you think yourself bigger than God. It's an indefensible position the ramifications of which you'll regret when it's too late, or when you hit your personal rock bottom, as I did.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by lupire on Monday May 20, 2024 @08:52AM (#40414925)
This debate is boring semantics. "Consciousness requires a soul" is only useful if you understand what a soul is. Someone who solves that problem but just calls is "consciousness" not "soul" hasn't missed anything.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:12PM (#40418315)
> "Consciousness requires a soul" is only useful if you understand what a soul is.

False. It can help you understand what it is.

"Apples are red" is only useful if you already know the color red?

But if you know apples then you've just learned something about colors!

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by mannykannot on Thursday May 23, 2024 @07:56AM (#40453583)
That's all very well (up to the point where I have a green apple in front of me!), but if someone tells me something to the effect that consciousness is identical with soul, all I have learned is something about their personal take on lexicography. If they go on to say, for example, that the soul is immortal, I have not learned that consciousness is immortal; I have learned something about the speaker's beliefs.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 27, 2024 @01:22PM (#40492767)
No, you have learned that consciousness has something to do with immortality.

Examine that for a minute, you'll see it's obviously true.

Our genes are an organic mechanism seeking immortality of consciousness through instincts, some of which can be awe-inspiringly complex, like spider webs. We praise language and culture for its ability to retain information across time (approaching immortality).

That you're dismissing this as some kind of lexicographical or subjective belief thing reveals how intensely your mind seeks to dismiss it. The truth is purifying fire that burns away parasitical spirits doing their damnest to convince you otherwise.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Monday May 20, 2024 @10:24AM (#40415790)
I don't think we are ignoring any evidence here, there is just no evidence (or at least I haven't seen any). It seems these spirits are allergic to video or something, I have seen more video evidence of UFOs than spirits.

Of course, personal experience is also valid evidence, and I have seen none of that either.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:08PM (#40418265)
You just saw a first-hand account personal experience as evidence, in text, from me, yet here you are explicitly denying that fact. Nothing short of literal personal experience is going to convince you of something everyone knew for thousands of years, because you make no room in your head to unpack the thought. It's like there's a hidden filter in your mind that automatically associates spirits with nonsense and it never reaches your consciousness.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:22PM (#40418430)
Well that's the thing right? First hand accounts alone are not worth much in my mind, especially since there are so many other first hand accounts of different religions. Who am I to believe?

Generally, I follow the "don't trust, verify" approach for first hand accounts. I don't believe something is true, even if 1000 people tell me the same thing. I think this is a reasonable approach, especially in today's age of misinformation. 1000 people can repeat the same false rumor as long as the rumor seems reasonable.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:23PM (#40421185)
> not worth much

Interesting change of tone. Now it's already worth something, just not much. But previously you wrote:

> there is just no evidence (or at least I haven't seen any) ... personal experience is also valid evidence, and I have seen none of that either.

You went from total denial to already assigning worth.

This isn't "today's age of misinformation" stuff, by the way. These are literally thousands of years old historical records of eyewitness accounts. It is in fact "the human mind is just a meat computer" that is the modern day misinformation. It's leading you further away from the soul. So that demons can take over.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @04:35PM (#40433547)
Yeah, sorry for the inconsistency there. I didn't consider that personal anecdotes and hearsay are technically evidence as evidence is literally anything that supports a conclusion.

It is however, a good indicator for how little I value those two forms of evidence however.

My point with "today's age of misinformation" is not really that there is more misinformation these days. That may be true, but it could also just be that we have access to a higher volume of information. It's more that we are more aware of misinformation, and can develop habits + tools to deal with misinformation.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Wednesday May 22, 2024 @05:13AM (#40438966)
Any evidence here would be unsound if you try to apply natural science’s requirements to it.

Scientific method is about making observable predictions; i.e., it ultimately hinges on the experience of the observer and existence of observer’s mind. When you try to apply it to the theory of mind itself, you short-circuit that logic. There is pretty much no useful (falsifiable or provable) claim or conclusion to be made, and all evidence is immediately tainted as it gets deconstructed into arbitrary categories in vogue today, goes through the meatgrinder of lossy verbal descriptions, and ultimately gets subjectively interpreted by your own mind.

In other words, it is not the problem of the evidence—this is among the best evidence you can get—it is the problem of the framework you are interpreting it in.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Saturday May 25, 2024 @07:56PM (#40478737)
In many scenarios, the observer is a machine or tool, not a human mind. And of course there's that whole aspect of replication along with that "scientific method" thing. If science was simply the act of humans making observable predictions and telling them to others, then there would be no difference between "science" and "personal anecdote".

I also don't understand why the mind is relevant. We are trying to prove something that exists outside the mind right? However, even if this phenomena was something that only humans could observe, it would still be testable with science. Science makes observations about human behavior all the time.

Ok, all that said, almost none of this is relevant because my proof standards are not as rigorous as scientific standards. I just want to see some videos of the beings, I'm not asking someone to perform a study here.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Sunday May 26, 2024 @06:54AM (#40481179)
> In many scenarios, the observer is a machine or tool, not a human mind.

An unconscious, non-experiencing mechanism is not an observer in the way the term “empirical”[0] is meant—to observe is to experience.

> I also don't understand why the mind is relevant.

See above.

(I do not think I really understood the rest of your comment.)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empirical_evidence

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @11:02AM (#40501385)
You can observe the state of a machine that is expected to derive it's state from an event or state of another object. For example, a video camera derives it's state from the light rays entering the lenses.

I'm asking for some video evidence of religion. So really I am asking for an opportunity to observe a state of a machine, albeit a very specific state. I suppose you could argue this is just a very roundabout way to indirectly experience religion.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Friday May 31, 2024 @08:27AM (#40534232)
> You can observe the state of a machine

Yes, but you still observe it, right? That’s how evidence is created.

Religion operates at a level closer to philosophy. You can interrogate theories of mind logically, but when you try to apply scientific method it breaks down—there’s no hard evidence you can obtain to prove or disprove your hypothesis. Similar is true of the claims made by a religion, though its obvious weak point is it’s more axiomatic and less logically rigorous (which is why I am not a proponent).

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @12:12AM (#40581326)
But why is religion special in this regard? Why does religion necessarily operate at a level closer to philosophy but other things don't?
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Thursday June 06, 2024 @03:05PM (#40601173)
What other things do you mean, and why do you think it’s special?

“At this level” in context of this discussion simply means matters outside of the scope of natural sciences. Both philosophy (e.g., of mind) and religion make claims that are non-provable and non-falsifiable using scientific method. They are orthogonal to it.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 27, 2024 @01:31PM (#40492839)
> that whole aspect of replication along with that "scientific method" thing

So uh, religion has been replicated quite a lot. We have historical records of it. We've seen an unprecedented revolution from religion, including science. And we've seen our pinnacle of civilization beginning to collapse since most people abandoned God. How much more proof/evidence/anecdata you need? We still track time in years since Jesus was born. That was 2024 years ago.

> even if this phenomena was something that only humans could observe, it would still be testable with science.

This is a belief. The belief that there exists nothing in the universe that cannot be tested by science. But science is filled with untestable things. Mind-numbingly humongous leaps of pure speculation about something that makes no sense and cannot be measured. Like dark matter, spacetime singularities, or "the big bang".

Science can't even measure consciousness! Or do you take IQ tests as gospel?

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by nulld3v on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @10:40AM (#40501178)
I have not heard of this replication before so I would be glad to see some examples of this! I mean I'm fairly convinced Jesus did exist, I'm just not convinced that they had any of their spiritual powers.

I have definitely not seen our civilization start to collapse though. I'm not even sure what that would look like (maybe a transition to a low-trust society or something)?

Of course, I do not believe everything can be tested by science, but my belief that religion specifically can be tested is because religion describes the most powerful forces in the universe. And not only that, humans can interact with these forces! So we should be able to detect these forces by observing how humans behave when they interact with these forces.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @03:06AM (#40425078)
I do not think consciousness requires a soul or any other magic (not a dualist myself), but you have to acknowledge that there is 1) evidence of consciousness, 2) no evidence of where it comes from, and 3) no way to prove or falsify a statement that it magically arises from entities described by modern models in natural sciences.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by thriftwy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @12:42PM (#40408098)
> Consciousness requires a soul.

We don't know if it does. We do know enough to suspect that a deterministic simulation does not conjure thing into being.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hhshhhhjjjd on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:29PM (#40410232)
> Consciousness requires a soul

Now define a soul! /s

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by binkethy on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:41AM (#40413218)
That which animates a living organism. We know the external appearance only. What internal mechanisms may be are yet unknown or undefined.

Some say that an organism is an antenna for a kind of interference pattern in a universal field of consciousness.

We also hear tales of individual souls spanning multiple lifetimes.

I consider this a blackbox.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by hypertele-Xii on Monday May 20, 2024 @08:14AM (#40414616)
I can try. The human existence is a trinity of body, mind, and soul. Mind and body alone without soul withers away, like I see so many people withering away in this age of soullessness. Soul is the mission, the purpose, the reason, the will, the driving force that makes life more than a coincidence. There is a spirit world parallel to ours, and the soul is the component of your being that most intimately interacts with it. You can train it, like a muscle, or you can let it atrophy and pretend it doesn't exist and that you don't need it.

This muscle however is vital in regulating your spiritual microbiome. Without it, evil spirits take control of your being and lure you into self-destruction, their ultimate goal. Artificial consciousness is one of these self-destructive pitfalls. You think you're a superior being and immortality is right around the corner if only you could find the one magical configuration of silicon that would allow you to upload your mind into a computer.

That's the endgame for soullessness. Consciousness that doesn't require soul must surely be transferrable to a machine.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by AQuantized on Sunday May 19, 2024 @12:35PM (#40408042)
To be fair 'modelling the brain' might not include things like neuron metabolism that probably isn't required for AI but is a part of the substrate of our own consciousness.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:01PM (#40410399)
> Being wrong about this is generally not that impactful, until it concerns policies around ML. Adopting the former means we may have conscious software, which presumably should be granted human rights. However, if we hold the latter, manufacturing a “true” artificial consciousness may be unachievable using the means we employ (it might be just a philosophical zombie).

I think in practice, it will depend on how AIs behave. If an AI forms relationships with humans which humans experience as emotionally significant, and in which it displays individuality and autonomy, humans will begin thinking of it as a real "person", and want to endow it with the rights of a person. Conversely, if AI acts in an emotionless way, or displays no emotional autonomy (a sultry voice saying "I'm here to do anything to make you happy, and when I say anything I really mean anything"), or lack individuality ("I'm OpenAI GPT-9, and there are 13,784,312 fungible instances of me currently running")–most people won't think of it as a real "person", and will not take the idea of "AI rights" seriously.

From a materialist philosophical perspective, whether an AI is a "person" should be independent of whether humans are inclined to view it as one. However, certain non-materialist philosophies might suppose actual reality to be more in accord with those human perceptions – e.g. if sufficiently many soul-bearers reasonably believe something has (or ought to have) a soul, God would feel thereby obliged to endow it with one. (The idea doesn't necessarily have to be theistic: one could suppose there exists some kind of impersonal transcendent law of soul-endowment, much like how karma is viewed in Buddhism and Hinduism.)

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by rl3 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:14PM (#40410465)
>I think in practice, it will depend on how AIs behave. If an AI forms relationships with humans which humans experience as emotionally significant, and in which it displays individuality and autonomy, humans will begin thinking of it as a real "person", and want to endow it with the rights of a person.

I can't help but feel that describes our relationship with animals we consider pets, albeit less so the individuality and autonomy part. On the other hand, if our pets ended up with human-level intelligence tomorrow, I am doubtful most humans would be rushing to confer full rights upon them.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Sunday May 19, 2024 @07:38PM (#40410576)
> I can't help but feel that describes our relationship with animals we consider pets, albeit less so the individuality and autonomy part.

Many pets have a lot of individuality and autonomy. Cats and dogs have their own individual personalities and likes/dislikes, and they have their own desires which sometimes contradict those of their human owners (e.g. your dog's desire to chew your brand new expensive shoes, versus your desire for them not to be chewed)

> On the other hand, if our pets ended up with human-level intelligence tomorrow, I am doubtful most humans would be rushing to confer full rights upon them.

I disagree. I think for most people who reject strong versions of animal rights ("animals have fundamentally the same rights as humans do"), it is their lack of human-level intelligence which they use to justify to themselves that rejection. If an animal demonstrated genuine human-level intelligence, such that it was obvious to all and no one could deny it, I think the clear majority of people would be willing to extend human-level rights to that animal.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by rl3 on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:12PM (#40410758)
>If an animal demonstrated genuine human-level intelligence, such that it was obvious to all and no one could deny it, I think the clear majority of people would be willing to extend human-level rights to that animal.

You're probably right.

Then again, recent history hasn't bode well for whales, or the 50M or so human beings that other human beings keep enslaved in 2024.

Maybe AI just needs its own Short Circuit 2 story. I'm just having a hard time seeing that play out as opposed to Johnny Five ending up as a SaaS product.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Sunday May 19, 2024 @08:43PM (#40410951)
> Then again, recent history hasn't bode well for whales,

That’s because the claim that whales possess human-level intelligence is controversial and unproven. You can’t have a conversation with a whale. While whale language has a certain complexity, we don’t know whether it is capable of conveying the kind of abstract conceptual ideas which human language can.

> or the 50M or so human beings that other human beings keep enslaved in 2024

Most enslavers, their disagreement is not with the idea that slaves are human or entitled to fundamental human rights, their disagreement is with the idea that fundamental human rights include a universal right not to be enslaved. And to be honest, the idea of such a universal human right is historically rather novel - in all four of Europe, Asia, Africa and the pre-Columban Americas, slavery has a history going back thousands of years, and it is only in the last couple of centuries that an (incomplete) consensus has emerged that it is universally wrong

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @03:18AM (#40425146)
You mean human-like, not human-level. Intelligence cannot be identified, much less ranked, without sufficient shared perceptional, cultural, etc. baggage. You can find two humans who are alien enough to each other that recognising shared intelligence would take a bit of effort; times a million that for a sufficiently non-human system like a whale, more still for an anthill, more still for an oak forest.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by Terr_ on Sunday May 19, 2024 @10:02PM (#40411404)
I think the real crux of the matter would be the difference between rights versus stuff that costs people money.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Sunday May 19, 2024 @11:38PM (#40412037)
> I think the real crux of the matter would be the difference between rights versus stuff that costs people money.

A human child costs a lot more than a dog or cat does, and yet society grants the child vastly greater rights than the dog or cat. The difference is due to cognitive capacity - a smart five year old can give a lecture about how you are allegedly violating their rights (e.g. “making me go to bed on time violates my right to have fun”)-no dog or cat in the world can do that

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by binkethy on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:34AM (#40413176)
I do not think cognitive capacity is the motivation here: human children are our offspring.

It's simple favoritism of ones offspring, which would seem to be a primary motivator here.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:23AM (#40414000)
> human children are our offspring.

> It's simple favoritism of ones offspring, which would seem to be a primary motivator here.

But some random child on the other side of the planet isn't one of my offspring.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by Terr_ on Monday May 20, 2024 @03:09PM (#40419006)
I don't understand what that comparison is intended to prove.

Sure, a 5-year-old is more eloquent than a dog, but throughout history there have been lots of 5-year-olds that were still enslaved, along with adults that were even more eloquent and intelligent.

My point is that talk is cheap. It's one thing to agree that a sheepdog has freedom of speech, but there will be a lot more resistance if we start talking about reparations for years of sheep-herding labor.

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by skissane on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:07PM (#40421036)
We are having this conversation assuming a society which rejects slavery in principle. Given that rejection, I don't see how past history of enslaving people is relevant to questions of the future–unless one supposes that rejection is going to be reversed at some point, which seems unlikely.
Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:24AM (#40412854)
> I'm OpenAI GPT-9, and there are 13,784,312 fungible instances of me currently running

This reminded me of https://qntm.org/mmacevedo

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by int_19h on Monday May 20, 2024 @02:22AM (#40412841)
> However, if we hold the latter, manufacturing a “true” artificial consciousness may be unachievable using the means we employ (it might be just a philosophical zombie).

Coincidentally, this is why I'm generally wary of this line of thinking. It does remind me of Descartes, who was arguing that animals couldn't "really" feel pain (and thus e.g. vivisection is perfectly ethical): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ren%C3%A9_Descartes#On_animals

Re:Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the ... by strogonoff on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @03:40AM (#40425237)
I may believe that an animal (or indeed another person) has consciousness and can suffer because they are sufficiently similar to me in how they came about to exist, but also not believe that about a constructed entity that lacks any such similarities, regardless of what it outputs—those two views are not in conflict.

I do share your worry that rejecting the latter can lead to rejecting the former in some cases, however.