Since the rule "you can't drink alcohol if you're underage" is one people are familiar with, they aren't being asked to make the same logical deduction they do in the letters and numbers question. I'd go further and speculate that they aren't all reading the question carefully - if you replaced the rule by "if someone is over 21 they are drinking beer", how many people would get it wrong?
It doesn’t: “If A then B” encodes it unambiguously.
It’s just that as you said, many people don’t think hard about the difference between this and similar-but-different concepts like “B only if A”.
It’s not the language itself, it’s the way people use the language and think about what it says (or in this case, don’t).
No, actually it doesn't
> Some authors have argued that participants do not read "if... then..." as the material conditional, since the natural language conditional is not the material conditional.
> It’s just that as you said, many people don’t think hard about the difference between this and similar-but-different concepts like “B only if A”.
While a nice simplistic answer it's likely not what's going on here. There is more here than "People just aren't good at thinking".
If your statement were true, then you'd be forced to say that the following statement is also obviously true:
"If the Nazis won World War II, then everybody would be happy"
The fact that you can rightfully say that sentence is false, means that your comment above about implication and "if" statements is wrong.[1] Language is more complex then you're giving it credit.
[1] - https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradoxes_of_material_implic...
I also think that if A then B is unambiguous, the counter that languages are different doesn't really fit with what I think I observe in the wild. For the full house, I also fail to see how that means I must accept that your example statement is obviously true.
For example if the cards have on one side either a picture of a mug of beer or a picture of a can of soda, and the other side have a number representing the age of a person drinking that drink, and the rule they are supposed to be checking is that if someone is drinking beer they have to be at least 21 then 75% of people correctly figure out that they need to check the other side of the cards showing beer and the cards showing an age under 21.
Here's Wikipedia's article on the Wason selection task [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wason_selection_task