Re:Evan - Twitter needs a better policy on Usernames
by dmv on Friday December 19, 2008 @06:59PM
(#404017)
Did you pick McDonalds.com because of this?
http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/2.10/mcdonalds.html
Because that's the first thing that came to mind reading this complaint. That was back in the wild days of the Internet, when official company spokespeople could say:
"Are you finding that the Internet is a
big thing?" asked Jane Hulbert, a helpful
McDonald's media-relations person, with
whom I spoke a short while ago.
Same thing here. 18 months ago, Twitter's namespace was considered worthless. Now Twitter leads to live commentary on cable television, celebrities use it, and companies need a Twitter Strategy.
Re:Evan - Twitter needs a better policy on Usernames
by tolmasky on Friday December 19, 2008 @11:04PM
(#404242)
This is nothing like that since its not a publicly-available domain (with ties to the govt. no less), but a private username.
If I held a party at my house where I gave out unique nametags, the Celtics wouldn't have the right over the one that said "celtics" on it.
Re:Evan - Twitter needs a better policy on Usernames
by webwright on Saturday December 20, 2008 @02:03AM
(#404376)
I guess I did mention the law, but that's not where I was going... But, yes, I know that Twitter has no legal obligation to any party. But if you agree that domain squatters should have to give up domain names to trademark holders, then the parallel holds.
It seems to be a conflict if you're in the same "domain". i.e. If I grab @celtics and talk about Celtic language and culture, it shouldn't be a conflict. If I grab it to build a following about the team, I'm piggybacking on the effort/expense of them building that brand and deserve to have it yanked.
IMO, it's very similar to the Nissan.com case - the owner of that domain is named Nissan and has a business with that name. He got there first, and he's got rights. However, if it was some random guy who put up a splash page or a nissan car site, it's trademark infringement, no?