Re:Next step in the Chrome OS journey
by mtgx on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @03:47PM
(#4039363)
ARM versions for half the price, please (preferably based on the latest Cortex A15 CPU and Mali GPU).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The cheapest option is $350 (a Cedar Trail board, the $450 one says "Intel Core" which probably means Sandy Bridge). What makes you think you can build an ARM board (with a core that doesn't even exist in the market yet!) for $175, much less sell it for that? The only device in the market that even comes close is the Kindle, and that's heavily subsidized by content revenue.
I meant half the price compared to the latest Chromebook from Samsung which is $450. They need at least a few models in the $200-$250 range, even if they have to make them "lower-end". But I think Cortex A15 will be a great match for that, unless they totally messed up the cross-platform optimization, and ChromeOS will be slower on ARM than on a similar-performance x86 chip. Plus, you'll get at least double the battery life - which is kind of necessary for a Web-only/mobility device.
OK, where are you going to find a $225 non-subsidized ARM box? Same logic applies. I see nothing even close to that range. A tablet or smartphone with these specs is going to run you $500+.
And you need to check (or better, run) a few benchmarks before making pronouncements like that. Per-clock, SNB beats the A9 in my OMAP4 phone by about 2x on stuff that fits in the L1 cache, and a bunch more on things that spill out (the phone SoC has absolutely nothing like the L3 cache on SNB).
http://www.genesi-usa.com/products/smartbook $200.
It's not very good when you're running Ubuntu, but then again even my nice i7 laptop can really suck under Linux sometimes. ChromeOS might help.
There are $250 Windows-based netbooks, where you actually have to pay a pretty big license cost..so..
I think it's very doable. I just don't think the manufacturers want to go that low because they want to exploit the early adopter market, and/or because Google was not ready with support for ARM.
Cortex A15 SoCs (specifically the Exynos 5 line, which includes ARM Mali GPUs) production didn't start until Q2, and I would assume they won't be ready until at least midway through Q3, so there's no way Google could use them in their Chrome OS devices.