News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by helipad on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:21AM (#4037572)
I wonder what would happen if Facebook ran a scheme like AdSense.

Advertising on the Facebook site itself seems not to be working, but I could foresee a situation where website owners allow Facebook to display ads on their site for a fee per click just like AdSense. Facebook already has a javascript presence on many, many websites already.

Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by brandnewlow on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:43AM (#4037672)
I used to think this as well, but there's a problem. What if FB ads are not as good a monetization solution for publishers as Google ads? This seems quite possible.

Facebook advertising is much much cheaper than Google advertising on a per-click and per-impression basis.

With Google ads, advertisers are used to paying as much as $20/click in some areas. I've never heard of a FB advertiser paying more than $2/click.

Likewise, CPMs on FB are in the single digit pennies quite often. On the web, banner ads are around $0.75 CPMs for decent sites.

Facebook might have looked at this and might believe that if they launched a network like this, the payouts just wouldn't be able to compete with what Google's able to give publishers.

Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by AznHisoka on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:38AM (#4037640)
Adsense makes up a minority of Google's ad profits. The billion dollar business is in Adwords, not Adsense.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by helipad on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:56AM (#4037740)
Indeed - I've no idea what the revenues would be - was just an idle thought.

Right now the problem is getting people to believe in Facebook's revenue to get some confidence back in the market.

Not saying it's is a silver bullet by any means.

Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by PelCasandra on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @11:08AM (#4037798)
Minority? It almost half of all Google ad profits.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by mda on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @11:57AM (#4038075)
It is more like Adwords: 70% Adsense: 30% http://investor.google.com/earnings/2012/Q1_google_earnings....
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by earl on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @02:47PM (#4039050)
sadly, no. Adsense is a $10B/year business. Even ex tac of 30%, that's still a big business.

From wikipedia [1]:

   In Q1 2011, Google earned US$2.43 billion ($9.71 billion annualized),
   or 28% of total revenue, through Google AdSense
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AdSense
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by shinchan on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:31AM (#4037611)
Wow. Its like you just read my mind! I was about to say the same thing. Indeed, especially since there are a lots of apps out there implementing Facebook login, especially mobile apps, games and apps alike, could this be a solution to their mobile strategy? (this is not a rhetorical question.) Whats stopping them from implementing this?
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by mkr-hn on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @11:12AM (#4037817)
I've never had good results from ticking the box for Google's display network in AdWords campaigns. The culprit is poor implementation by webmasters, not the amount or detail of data available. I don't see why a Facebook display network would do any better.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by alain94040 on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @02:22PM (#4038910)
They'll do it as soon as they are confident that they can pay websites more per click than AdSense. It's a winner-take-all market.

But AdSense is very vulnerable: intent (the search string), which is the one reason Google advertising works, is absent from AdSense.

As an example, I once wrote a blog post with a title like "startup financing: take the elevator, not the stairs". Google placed ads on that post for Thyssen elevators. It had just no clue that the topic was startups, not actual elevators. Not impressed.

Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by earl on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @02:41PM (#4039015)
Google uses search activity from the past several hours to help match ads in adsense for content[1]. Hiding those from other ad networks is, imo, one of the best reasons they should be sued for antitrust.

   We've recently started to expand the use of the query words in referral
   URLs to a few hours so we can so we can continue to deliver more relevant
   ads. The technical way that we're doing this is by associating the
   relevant query words in the referral URL with the existing advertising
   cookie on the user's browser. After a short period of time (a few hours)
   the query words are no longer used for the purposes of matching ads.
[1] http://adsense.blogspot.com/2010/02/better-contextual-matchi...
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by maxerickson on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @03:46PM (#4039351)
That article doesn't discuss the details of the implementation, but it could very well be the Adsense js that is tagging the cookie with the referral data. Any ad network can implement that.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by earl on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @04:32PM (#4039677)
Perhaps I wasn't clear. Google is hiding referer data, particularly the query string, for a growing number of searchers. Today it's anyone logged into google, or about 60% of traffic to my blog. Tomorrow, they may well do it for anyone. Right now for the logged in users, and potentially in the future for anyone, the only ad network that can still see the search terms in the referer string is adsense, because Google search can pass them to adsense internally. No other ad network can see them. This is obviously incredibly valuable for adsense. And it should trigger an antitrust violation because they're using their monopoly / near monopoly in search to juice their offsite context and display ad networks.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by maxerickson on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @05:51PM (#4040156)
No, you weren't particularly clear. Mostly because if Google is sharing data between search and adsense internally, it doesn't have anything to do with Adsense storing referrer data anymore.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by earl on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @06:24PM (#4040315)
Quoting me:

   Google uses search activity from the past several hours to help match
   ads in adsense for content[1]. Hiding those from other ad networks is,
   imo, one of the best reasons they should be sued for antitrust.
So: Google is a monopoly / near monopoly search engine in the US and Europe. Many ad networks use the query string located in the referer from outgoing search clicks to help target ads. AFC, a Google owned and operated ad network, uses this information as per blog post linked by me somewhere in this thread.

Google has recently started hiding search query strings by stripping them from the referrer for logged in users and has made noise that sounds like this will eventually happen for all users. This hurts ad networks because it removes some of the intent they use to help target ads, and crucially hurts the most when trying to target ads on low information pages. However, Google can certainly internally continue to give this information to adsense in order to target content. This is the sort of thing antitrust law is meant to prevent: using a monopoly in one area (search and sem) to juice your business elsewhere (display ad network).

Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by maxerickson on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @06:49PM (#4040392)
I understand that you are complaining about https. I'm pointing out that the article you linked doesn't provide any insight into what data Google is sharing internally.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by earl on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @07:37PM (#4040562)
Google is known -- by their own blog! -- to use this data for ad targeting. Until they say they aren't, it's more than reasonable to assume they continue to use it for ad targeting. They are certainly aware of other ad networks using the search query string: employees have mentioned it in conference talks. If they were using no more information than any other ad network has access to, it would be trivial for them to publicly say so. Until then, I suggest writing the FTC.
Re:Facebook Advertising is Fool's Gold by mootothemax on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:46AM (#4037689)
I wonder what would happen if Facebook ran a scheme like AdSense.

Maybe that is/was one of the aims behind the Like button? Facebook could use that connection to tailor the adverts displayed to the user (along with the site's content!), provided the user is logged into Facebook at the time.

Admittedly, I think doing so would kick up a bit of a stink ;)