Re:Apple's Crystal Prison and the Future of Open Platforms
by zatara on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @09:32AM
(#4037355)
Hi saurik,
I just would like to thank you for the wonderful job you did (and do) with Cydia. Jailbreaking and Cydia access is my first priority on any iOS device I buy, and I could never imagine myself buying another iPad/iPhone if Cydia stopped existing. IMHO you are not competing with Apple, but rather augmenting their ecosystem and keeping users like myself from drifting towards Android.
Re:Apple's Crystal Prison and the Future of Open Platforms
by onedev on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @09:51AM
(#4037442)
Hey Jay! Thanks for everything man, just wanted to take this chance to say that. I've had so much fun thanks to Cydia and it's been really useful.
Re:Apple's Crystal Prison and the Future of Open Platforms
by mark_integerdsv on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @03:32AM
(#4041805)
Just joining the chorus: great work on Cydia. I have had hours of fun and I am yet to use an iOS device unjailbroken by choice for more than an hour or two.
(Honestly, if you could distribute something in the App Store, and are coming to Cydia instead, you are going to get some funny looks on my end. Cydia is not about accepting the App Store's rejects, nor is it about competing with the App Store. It is a way to distribute things fundamentally unlike the things in the App Store: extensions, not apps.)
Frankly, every time anyone--the EFF included--makes the argument that this somehow comes down to sales numbers and revenue competition, it just undermines the cause. :( That really sucks, as I think this is a serious issue and there really are good arguments to be made, but instead everyone just latches on to this simple-but-wrong direct revenue idea.
(For those who then ask "ok, what are some of those arguments?", I will direct you to the comments I sent to the copyright office for this year's round of exemption requests. I focus on things like cross-market control and the stifling of non-app innovation. You can also, however, make arguments about consumer control, purchase longevity, and security.)
http://www.copyright.gov/1201/2012/comments/Jay_Freeman.pdf