Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by CoastalCoder on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @01:14PM
(#40369703)
> The ends of the spectrum are clearly immoral, and perfectly OK, respectively.
I'd agree that it's probably a spectrum of legal culpability (although IANAL, so...)
But I disagree that the extrema are clearly moral or immoral.
For example, I expect that the private, hand-drawn scenario violates Christian morality.
And I'm guessing there are other moral frameworks that are sincerely held by some persons, and which are okay with the other extremity.
Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by marcus_holmes on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:42PM
(#40375002)
I'm kinda fascinated by the Christian morality thing - I was raised Anglican and while I no longer believe I still have a fair understanding of the dogma. How does drawing a picture of someone violate that morality?
There are realistic pictures (and sculptures) of real people all over our churches. Are these immoral?
I think possibly the confusion lies in my framing of the question; I meant drawing a picture of someone at all, not necessarily someone naked or having sex.
Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by matt-attack on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @09:26PM
(#40374307)
Sadly CP laws do not recognize that one end of that spectrum is OK. If I draw a photo realistic drawing (or even non photo realistic, ie anime) of CP Iām a felon in the eyes of our pathetic laws.
Paparazzi take photos of people without their consent, and sell them for money. We tend to think this is immoral but legal, and making it illegal would cause more problems than it solves. There is no restriction about such photos being naked or clothed.
Making a deepfake uses someone's likeness. Is that the same as drawing a recognisable picture of them? If not, where do we draw the line between the two? If it is, should we make drawing a picture of someone without their consent illegal? That seems too far to me.
The law is going to take a while to catch up to this. Meanwhile, making this Google's problem seems perfectly OK to me. You create a ludicrously profitable monopoly on discovery, then you get to deal with the problems that people have with discovery <shrug>.