Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by vouaobrasil on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:17AM
(#40367273)
> Passing legislation is a necessary first step. Do we really want to set a precedent where Google is expected to proactively censors content that is, for all intents and purposes, legal?
I would expect that in a sane society, everyone would do their part to stop something from happening when that thing is clearly bad, even if it is technically legal!
Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by tekla on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @11:16AM
(#40368068)
"clearly bad" is doing a fuck ton of work here.
Re:Downranking won't stop Google's deepfake porn problem, vi...
by richbell on Wednesday May 15, 2024 @10:26AM
(#40367392)
Within reason, sure. I don't think the demands being made are reasonable. Google is already doing their part to stop it from spreading, but they aren't the source.
Compare that to something like malicious ads, which Google has full control over and directly benefits from.
> Google's spokesperson told Ars that in addition to lowering the links in the search results, Google is "continuing to decrease the visibility of involuntary synthetic pornography in Search" and plans to "develop more safeguards as this space evolves.”
> ...
> “Google has ruined lives and is shamefully inflexible at responding to developing problems,” Goldberg said, joining others decrying Google's move as "too little, too late."
> Google's solution still largely puts the onus on victims to surface deepfakes and request removals, seemingly mostly because Google only proactively removes web results when content directly conflicts with the law or its content policies.
While I'm usually highly critical of Google, it seems like they're already doing what they reasonable can? Google isn't hosting this content.
Passing legislation is a necessary first step. Do we really want to set a precedent where Google is expected to proactively censors content that is, for all intents and purposes, legal?