No, they would be better off if they had known what the pilots were doing and stopped the fraud rather than allowing it.
> If there were potentially harsh penalties for allowing this to happen, regardless of knowledge, I think you’d see much better controls put in place, and the incentive would be to keep safety critical operations kept in-house, where they can be better monitored, rather than spun out to make the return on capital look better to public markets.
If you made inaccurate reports to governments a strict liability crime with a harsh pubishment not requiring intent, recklessness,or negligence, I think that would actually be a bad thing and lead people to actively avoid any activity or field of business that might require reporting to the government.
But, in any case, the fraud offenses at issue ARE NOT strict liability crimes now, so people without the requisite knowledge and intent cannot be guilty of them.
Of course, i am in the camp of changing the regulation such that outcomes that would be considered gross neglegence leading to loss of life is layed on the management, regardless of whether the decision is diffused or not. Aka, they hold the statutory responsibility, and is criminally liable - that's the price of being in management. They would get the tools as management to put in place preventative measures, which can be used to cover their ass.
So if you have a pension, should we be locking you up 'cause it was partially invested in Boeing?
Alternatively, you can have a specifically named role which is to be held liable? But then as far as the 'company' is concerned it's still just cost of doing business.
There's only three viable ultimate sanctions for a corporate entity: financial, being split up, and the death penalty.