Re:What Factors Explain the Nature of Software?
by bmitc on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @11:25AM
(#40356192)
What is The Cathedral and the Bazaar about? I couldn't quite tell from a cursory glance.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What Factors Explain the Nature of Software?
by gavinhoward on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @11:30AM
(#40356258)
Disclaimer: been a while since I read it.
It compares two software development styles. It compares typical software dev in a company to building a cathedral: directions come from on high, and you execute your task.
Then it compares typical Open Source development, such as with the Linux kernel, and compares it to a bazaar: everyone is doing their own thing, but somehow, things get done.
It's old, and maybe a little outdated now that the corporate world has taken over Open Source, but I would still suggest reading it.
Re:What Factors Explain the Nature of Software?
by bmitc on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @09:19PM
(#40362071)
Yea, but I guess I was looking for something deeper, because at the outset, I'd be a little offput by the suggestion to read it and any disagreement about my disagreement on it. And I fully understand the issues described by the above parent. The book comes off as a bit opinionated with the blinders of a Linux kernel development and 80-90s attitude about open source software. That's a pretty narrow focus of software development.
For example:
> Every good work of software starts by scratching a developer's personal itch.
I've written good software professionally, but none of it was kickstarted by my own personal itch.