ChatGPT doesn't have that sort of thing currently, and until it does it will always be really bad at that sort of thing.
You are using a hand to hammer a nail, that will never go well, the solution isn't to use more hands the solution is to wield a hammer.
When your muscle memory is instinctively clicking that start button, it's more akin to a very strong weighting after many sessions of reinforcement learning. Our brains may still be dumb but we can quickly say things like 1+1=...2 because we used reinforcement learning to strengthen the weighting back in primary school. We're not sitting visualising an abacus moving in our minds.
At that point they'll still have a tendency to use a stereotyped response and stick with it, instead of a thoughtful response, but you can try to address that in prompting too by asking for multiple proposals before choosing one.