Re:Ask HN: Where does consciousness come from?
by yters on Friday December 19, 2008 @11:15AM
(#403459)
Can you describe the most convincing evidence for reincarnation?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ask HN: Where does consciousness come from?
by FlorinAndrei on Friday December 19, 2008 @08:30PM
(#404104)
Reincarnation is of secondary importance to buddhism, and indeed it gives the impression of a "bolted on" feature that was added later on to, presumably, satisfy the masses.
The most strict interpretations of the buddhist doctrine actually posit the unreality of reincarnation.
(n.b.: I am not a buddhist)
Re:Ask HN: Where does consciousness come from?
by rodrigo on Friday December 19, 2008 @11:36AM
(#403489)
I dont view reincarnation as "me" waking up in some other body in some other time;
IMHO it has to be on a gene level, "me" is just a bunch of genes wich have learned and contribute to the general pool.
Or something like that.
Re:Ask HN: Where does consciousness come from?
by yters on Friday December 19, 2008 @11:40AM
(#403492)
Well, then anything adaptive is "reincarnation." You might as well just call it "adaptation," then, instead of redefining another word.
Re:Ask HN: Where does consciousness come from?
by rodrigo on Friday December 19, 2008 @01:40PM
(#403659)
Thats it, i normally dont say "reincarnation".
It seems to me that words like that were used to make graspable a concept thats hard to grasp; but it lost its sense when someboy tried to hard to make it fit in some view of things.
Edit: It can also be called Evolution.