News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brain Uses Quantum Effects, New Study Finds by zztop44 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @08:30PM (#40338654)
I think your mistake is to take “free will” to be something that exists or could exist (ie: in the same realm as physical forces). Which is, of course, just as “outside of physics” as the concept of a spirit or God.

“Free will” is a cultural-linguistic construct. How could it be anything else? The very concepts of discrete individuals, let alone agency, is effectively arbitrary as far as physical forces are concerned.

The “things” that free will concern are already many, many layers of abstractions (and cultural-linguistic construction) away from the individual deterministic interactions of what we currently understand to be physics.

And, like all abstractions, these are leaky and imprecise. So trying to model or analyse their behavior in terms of deterministic physical interactions has always seemed misguided to me.

Re:Brain Uses Quantum Effects, New Study Finds by galaxyLogic on Monday May 13, 2024 @03:52AM (#40340745)
Let's also think about Quantum Mechanics. It says the world is non-deterministic. A photon basically has FREE WILL to decide which slit it goes through in the double-slit experiment.

The Laws of Physics cannot dictate whether Schrodinger's cat dies because an atomic reaction happens, only that there is a specific probability for that happening.

So if the world is not deterministic neither are human brains. Physics cannot dictate what the brains think, it can only dictate what the probabilities for some neuron pathways opening or closing are.

Re:Brain Uses Quantum Effects, New Study Finds by caf on Monday May 13, 2024 @04:28AM (#40340964)
A better example than the double-slit experiment might be: you observe a single free neutron. Exactly when will it decay?
Re:Brain Uses Quantum Effects, New Study Finds by galaxyLogic on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @01:07AM (#40351791)
Exactly.
Re:Brain Uses Quantum Effects, New Study Finds by Zecc on Monday May 13, 2024 @06:01AM (#40341450)
I equate it with saying water doesn't exist because it's all just hydrogen and oxygen. Wait, I meant sub-atomic particles.