News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by 542458 on Saturday May 11, 2024 @08:42AM (#40327712)
> patents don't apply to private tinkering unless there's commerce involved.

While you’re unlikely to be sued for something you do in your basement that has no broader commercial or cultural impact, it’s not impossible. There is no private use exemption to patents.

https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/24148/can-i-build-so...

Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by h4ckerle on Saturday May 11, 2024 @11:59AM (#40328926)
As always with laws this is very location specific. In germany there is a very clear clause about patents not applying to "Actions carried out in the private sphere for non-commercial purposes" (§11 PatG, own translation)
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by kwhitefoot on Saturday May 11, 2024 @04:04PM (#40330326)
Also the patents in question are probably software patents which, in theory, are not granted in Europe.
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by denschub on Saturday May 11, 2024 @07:48PM (#40331354)
"I'm in Europe so I don't have to care because software patents are not enforceable here" isn't the solution. Yes, patent law doesn't apply - but copyright law does, and they very much can take down content that references the spec just based on copyright law alone.
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by fulafel on Sunday May 12, 2024 @04:20AM (#40332979)
In a lot of european countries there's specific legislation allowing computing interop that overrides copyright. Eg https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/computer-...

(Also I'd think copyright in EU doesn't normally apply to implementing protocols as it's supposed to grant monopolies of creative expression? but IANAL)

Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by nostrademons on Saturday May 11, 2024 @10:48AM (#40328420)
Something surprising that a couple lawyers have drilled into me: you can be sued for anything, regardless of whether it's illegal or not. The lawsuit is the discovery & decision process by which the courts decide whether your personal circumstances make it illegal. If the law is blatantly on your side you can get the lawsuit thrown out, but you still have to defend yourself, which includes the expense of hiring a lawyer.

A corollary (and probably what the lawyers were getting at): not making yourself a target is more valuable than actually following the law. If you have money, keep it to yourself - some more unscrupulous actors will find some legal grey area you're operating in and sue you for it simply so they can force a settlement and get some of it. If you're doing something interesting (whether it's legal or not), keep it to yourself. If your interests are not aligned with someone else, gosh darnit, don't tell them or otherwise bring yourself to their attention. There is probably some lawsuit they can bring that would at least force an expensive court case and legal defense and make you want to settle to make it all go away.

And once you are a target anyway, follow the law scrupulously. This is why big corporations invest billions in legal & compliance departments.

Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by mik1998 on Saturday May 11, 2024 @05:16PM (#40330680)
Really only a thing in the USA due to the ridiculous American rule wrt. attorney fees.
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by samatman on Saturday May 11, 2024 @10:22AM (#40328272)
This isn't 100% true, it's closer to 90% true.

There is a narrowly-tailored "research exemption" to patents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Research_exemption

So "private tinkering" where you implement something patented in order to perform research is permitted, but not for one's own benefit, even privately. For the example we're discussing, implementing Thread on some IoT device in order to benchmark it in various ways is in-bounds, but you can't use that device to your own benefit, even privately in your own home.

Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by eszed on Saturday May 11, 2024 @11:49AM (#40328845)
Aye. And, as the sibling post points out, demonstrating that your benchmarking project qualifies for a Research Exemption could devolve into a lawyer-up situation.
Re:Thread – the tech we can't use or teach by fulafel on Sunday May 12, 2024 @03:50AM (#40332867)
Huh, TIL that there are jurisdictions like this. Not in my part of the world.