You seem to think I have to prove your model false to show others don't do that. But I am specifically not claiming your model is false. I'm saying folks don't think that way, necessarily. For example, many build lists for shopping that they were taught. Not that they reasoned.
Most people learn to build lists through mimicry. They literally mimic the lists they were taught they need to build to go to the store. With enough experience, many of us learn to build our own lists from other principals, but it almost all starts with mimicry and simulation. Is why "going shopping" is such a fun game for kids. They are learning.
None of which is to say that you can't make your thinking better with logic. You almost certainly can. But you are begging the question with your examples and explanations. Heavily.
You're attempting a sleight of hand here by saying "they're" not "doing trig". Clearly they are not doing anything like that consciously, but equally clearly some part of their brain is triangulating objects and predicting trajectories based on gradients, meaning that part is "doing trig and calculus" subconsciously. What else does it mean to "do something" if not "process X is isomorphic to process Y"?
> You can /model/ it that way. But you are making a symbolic model to justify how a solution is reached.
I really don't understand what you think people are doing when they're compiling a grocery list. They're clearly thinking, "I need x AND y OR I can substitute z".
Or if they're planning to paint their fence, they're thinking, "I need paint AND brushes AND I have to start before lunch OR I won't finish before dinner".