It is a matter of corporate domination of technology and restriction of use through signed packages and security. ;)
Which do you want?
The harsh truth is we've tried the 'run whatever you want' model and it sucks ass for the end user as they get infested with malware.
I say, which do you want?
I really don't buy that Apple's absurdly draconian control is better than something akin to Chrome's warnings. You should make it difficult to install something potentially malicious by accident our without thought, but you should definitely not go out of your way to stop determined users from installing what they want either! Apple goes well beyond the reasonable and helpful and into the absurd.
My point stands, we tried the run anything model and millions of machines are infested with malware as anyone with any basic computer experience can attest.The number of times I've had to clean friends or families computers I cannot count. There is a very good argument for these sandboxes.
To tell the story again: my brother runs a cash intensive business that regularly moves hundreds of thousands of dollars a month. He narrowly escaped having a mid six figure sum stolen after his computer was hacked, and his solution now is to have a separate laptop that is only used for accessing the bank website and not a single other site on the internet. He's not stupid, he makes way more money than the majority of people reading this, and he finished a math undergrad with honors. And yet his computer got spyware on it that harvested the bank login. It's time to admit that our current security models have absolutely failed their users. At least on an ipad it's more likely than not that an application that will run is safe to run.
BTW, many non-developer will always be bound to what their distro provide them with. I am OK with that, as long as I can override all these security restrictions whenever I want and for whatever reason.
I think that Chromebook-like operating systems could provide an interesting middle-ground. By default the system is locked down and only Google can update the software. At the same time you can unlock the bootloader whenever you want and install your own things if you want to escape the walled garden.
The Android app stores have some housekeeping problems. There are apps that shouldn't be in there because they're malicious. Is it restricting "freedom" to prevent people from installing these?
Cory is turning into a cantankerous crank lately. The future is not these general purpose computation platforms, naturally it is smaller more application focused devices that provide a safe environment for the user.
I can imagine he'd be railing against roads a hundred years ago as "the coming war on general driving" because they restrict a person's freedom to drive anywhere they want.
At the same time, users have never had more options when it comes to free and open in other spaces like Arduino or the new ARM-based machines. People can get a very capable computer for $25-35 and run a robust open-source environment like Ubuntu on it. What more do you want?
Nonsense. Or you could as well talk about "freedom to not hear unhealthy opinions", "freedom from the burden of choosing your profession", etc.
How about "freedom from unnecessarily dangerous professions" where you won't have to concern yourself with being just another casualty in the factory?
Usually when people "give up" freedom they're just trading it for a different form.
It is extremely liberating for non-technical people to be able to browse an app store catalog and install things without concern that it will wreck their device.
Go tell that to the many people who are fighting for more freedom.
You expect me to have sympathy for people that are whinging about their iPhone not being as open as their Raspberry Pi? Where's your rage about refrigerators or washing machines? Why isn't your car's firmware open-source?
You want freedom, you can get freedom. You want a polished, appliance-like phone, you can choose that.
The problem is when it is the hardware manufacturer that dictates which signatures are to be trusted and which are not. The user should be the one that is free to choose the software that runs on its hardware, not the hardware maker.
I suggest «The coming war on general computation: the copyright war was just the beginning» by Cory Doctorow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg .