Re:Walled Gardens are Driving me to JavaScript
by sirclueless on Sunday May 27, 2012 @05:34PM
(#4031072)
Don't forget UEFI, which has the potential to make a large segment of consumer devices unbootable under linux and also invalidate your point b). If you think that walled-garden software signing is in the future, why wouldn't you expect that signing to be implemented straight down to a hardware level?
Re:Walled Gardens are Driving me to JavaScript
by laughinghan on Sunday May 27, 2012 @06:05PM
(#4031156)
b) If you have physical layer access, you can override any security settings. Gatekeeper et al cannot change this fact. You will be able to write/run code, just not necessarily distribute it.
That is not necessarily true. It is a "simple"[1] matter to have non-overridable security programming arbitrarily close to core hardware, from a chip on the motherboard to etched directly into the same silicon as the processor or BIOS. This isn't just a theoretical concern: plans to do this are already underway, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UEFI#Secure_Boot
[1]: By "simple" I mean the concept is simple, the implementation is plenty complicated.
a) Money is a bit of a red herring. Or rather, if Apple gave away keys for free, would you no longer have a problem?
b) If you have physical layer access, you can override any security settings. Gatekeeper et al cannot change this fact. You will be able to write/run code, just not necessarily distribute it.
c) Code signing will nuke a large portion of malware. 99% of users are not developers, so why should the default state of the operating system be configured for our needs?
d) Code signing could be implemented on a javascript level, as well. Flash is/was an attempt at signed codebases/binaries distributed over the web. Presumably, for example, a site could required to pull resources from an HTML5 manifest style local cache that has been signed/verified. This could eliminate MITM style attacks (changing ads) that are already in use. Difficult? Yes. Impossible? No.
e) There's always Linux/BSD. Until the TPM security protocols of 2018 are implemented, of course.