News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by pg on Saturday May 26, 2012 @01:55PM (#4027875)
I could see why Microsoft would do something like this, but why Apple? Does anyone know?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by coderdude on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:43PM (#4028003)
This seems more like an Apple move than a Microsoft move. It's a pretty common opinion nowadays that Apple is the worst in the bunch; beating the pants off any unethical stuff Microsoft might be up to -- or was up to even back in the day. I'd imagine Microsoft just needed to be on board so that they didn't get left out and screwed over by this down the line.

I am completely mystified by how these companies get together and work with each other on things like this.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by astrodust on Saturday May 26, 2012 @06:46PM (#4028620)
> It's a pretty common opinion nowadays...

Apple is not the worst of the bunch. You have nothing to qualify that statement other than a hand-waving gesture.

The undisputed #1 king of patent trolls is former Microsoft CTO Nathan Myhrvold's company Intellectual Ventures and its various holding companies that sue anyone and everyone with patents that contain no technology but do contain lots of language that's very lawsuit friendly as the claims are sweepingly broad. Recently they tried to sue a large number of small developers that were using "in app purchasing" technology.

Number two is Microsoft who is extorting upwards of $15 per Android phone sold from a number of vendors as part of their "fair licensing" program even though zero Microsoft code is used in those phones.

Number three would be Oracle if only they could get better lawyers and a more agreeable jury.

Apple has been fighting to push back at the tide of design violations put forward by companies like Samsung and others. If you can name even one instance of where Apple has directly sued a small company over a technology patent I would be surprised.

You seem to have absolutely no idea what Microsoft was up to "even back in the day" because it was far worse than anything Apple has ever done. Remember the bait-and-switch with OS/2? The pricing scheme where DOS was $60 and the very same DOS + Windows was $30? Where companies like Dell had to pay a license fee on every machine sold regardless of if it was sold with Windows or not? The way they would switch up Windows to "break" other competing applications like WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3?

You seem to have forgotten that it was an arms-length Microsoft deal that enabled SCO to turn zombie and threatening hundreds if not thousands of companies that were simply using Linux, not even developing their own software.

The reason you're completely mystified is because you haven't done any research.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by yuhong on Sunday May 27, 2012 @01:07AM (#4029312)
"Remember the bait-and-switch with OS/2? "

Ah, one of my favorite topics. Why did it take ten years after Intel released the 386 before 32-bit protected mode apps become common? Yea, the MS/IBM JDA was not particularly good, but the alternative MS took was much worse.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by astrodust on Sunday May 27, 2012 @08:09AM (#4029962)
There was Windows 386 but that hardly counts as it was for multi-tasking DOS applications, something Desqview had already done for years.

What was shocking, as you hint at, was how Microsoft, which had been encouraging OS/2 as their "serious" OS for years, dumped that and somehow managed to convince people that Windows 3.1 was better.

It was like going from a space ship to a party full of clowns. Wasn't it possible to write Windows apps in 16 bit mode then?

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by recoiledsnake on Sunday May 27, 2012 @11:22AM (#4030235)
>Apple has been fighting to push back at the tide of design violations put forward by companies like Samsung and others. If you can name even one instance of where Apple has directly sued a small company over a technology patent I would be surprised.

Is this some sort of revisionist history? What about these ~20 patents? I'd like to know which ones you consider as design patents.

http://www.engadget.com/2010/03/02/apple-vs-htc-a-patent-bre...

I am not even going to waste my time listing patents used to sue Motorola and Samsung because I believe you're the one trying to handwave things here.

>The pricing scheme where DOS was $60 and the very same DOS + Windows was $30

God forbid a company set the price of its own products according to competitive pressures. What next? Kindle Fire should be banned?

>The way they would switch up Windows to "break" other competing applications like WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3?

Care to elaborate or provide references? Is there really a case of WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3 running well on one version of Windows and breaking on the next?

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by Arare on Sunday May 27, 2012 @01:32PM (#4030541)
>Number two is Microsoft who is extorting upwards of $15 per Android phone sold from a number of vendors as part of their "fair licensing" program even though zero Microsoft code is used in those phones.

Where are you getting this from? this has never been proven and is built on pure speculation. Without a doubt they're earning some money from patent deals, but 15$ per unit sold? unlikely.

>The pricing scheme where DOS was $60 and the very same DOS + Windows was $30?

What? Microsoft are evil because they sold products cheaper than the rest of the market? Please think about what you just wrote.

>The way they would switch up Windows to "break" other competing applications like WordPerfect and Lotus 1-2-3?

Microsoft "switched up" windows up with a newer objectively better version of there operating system, Why is it there fault that Novell couldn't adapt to already standard technology used in other operating systems? I don't remember Lotus 1-2-3 ever having an issue running on windows, perhaps you could fill me in because I only ran this software for 15 years.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by eridius on Saturday May 26, 2012 @04:44PM (#4028306)
Citation please. Your "common opinion" has never actually been backed up with any evidence that I've seen.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by coderdude on Saturday May 26, 2012 @06:02PM (#4028522)
You want a citation that proves it's a common opinion now? People express that opinion on here all the time. You're not going to find them in the Apple threads, obviously. Or do you want me to painstakingly back up this opinion with citations of how their closed ecosystem, strong arming (or outright disallowing) of their competition in the app store, and patent bullying is making them evil?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by Steko on Saturday May 26, 2012 @06:19PM (#4028556)
He wants you to justify your claim. Obviously you can't so I guess loud noises are in order.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by coderdude on Saturday May 26, 2012 @06:53PM (#4028633)
I don't owe him 30 minutes of my time. Simply because I don't choose to fulfill his request for information does not mean that I'm here to make "loud noises." If he was actually interested and not just challenging my point because he doesn't share my opinion then he could have done this...

https://www.google.com/search?q=how+is+apple+evil

...to get an idea of what I meant by common opinion. That "citation please" thing is a quick and easy way to try and derail anyone's argument who isn't willing to spend real time digging crap up. It's perfectly fine by me if this makes me "lose the argument."

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by Steko on Saturday May 26, 2012 @07:17PM (#4028678)
OTOH a quick and easy way to make your argument is to claim everyone holds it.

Let's inspect your claim:

"It's a pretty common opinion nowadays that Apple is the worst in the bunch; beating the pants off any unethical stuff Microsoft might be up to -- or was up to even back in the day."

Let's examine your first piece of evidence: they have a closed ecosystem.

Let examine something MS is famous for doing back in the day: destroying Netscape

No one in their right mind would put these in the same league, I don't know why you nonchalantly claim not only that they are but Apple's worse and that this "beats the pants off" MS in the evilness department.

Let's examine another one of your pieces of evidence: the removal of RA's app because it reverse engineered a private API or something.

Let's compare this to something else MS was famous for back in the day: bankrolling SCO's attempt to kill linux.

Well clearly again if we had a scale of evilness with Nathan Myrvold being a 10 and Hitler 100, MS might be a solid 6-8 and Apple maybe a 1-3.

So you can keep defending what you said til the end of time but I'm going to call it total bullshit and be done with it here.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by astrodust on Saturday May 26, 2012 @11:44PM (#4029135)
Let's see. I've heard this argument before. Oh, right, that's because it's on the Logical Fallacies chart (https://s3.amazonaws.com/yourlogicalfallacyis/pdf/LogicalFal...)!

It's the "bandwagon fallacy" where just because an opinion is popular it must be true.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by elemeno on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:38PM (#4027991)
It wouldn't be too far fetched to imagine that it's simply because Apple knows that some of the patents involved are ones which cover areas they're working in and so by being part of the consortium that owns them they're covering themselves against potential problems in the future.

Once you're part of consortium, you might as well be part of the group looking for potential infringers. It behoves you to protect your investment and it provides potential ways to protect yourself in the future by being able to force cross-licensing deals if it turns out that you're infringing on someone else's patent(s) - these are supposed to be fairly fundamental patents so there's a good chance that who ever is suing you is going to be infringing on one of them, or else licensing it already.

This is a far better article about it - http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2012/05/rockstar/all/1

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by buster on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:13PM (#4027936)
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by pg on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:18PM (#4027945)
Oh, was it Steve's anger about Android copying iOS? I could see that sort of bitterness making a company behave in a way that would otherwise be out of character.

Is that the consensus about why Apple did this?

If it is, could Apple undo the damage now that it's in more moderate hands? Or have they effectively set off a giant, evil autonomous robot that can't be stopped?

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by buster on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:51PM (#4028023)
I think, it's not out of character per se, but Apple will be very threatened by the rise of Android. Android now leads the market (afaik), which was Apples position for years. Now, they only have two options in the current system:

  - change strategy
  - sue
Obivously, a huge company like Apple won't just change its strategy. Just building the fancy products they do got them at this point but may not get them much further. To sue is (sadly) the only other way to hold off competition.

What that change in strategy may be, i don't know. Maybe more openness and try to break out of the walled garden they build..

There is only little space left in the niche that Apple occupies (selling expensive tech products to people that can afford it), especially when there is so much competition in the whole market. Apple had a major advantage for years in the market with the iPod and iPhone and i will be really impressed if they can think of the next big thing(tm). If Apple can't come up with the next big product and just keeps going, they may only be able to sue to hold off competition.

That's only talking about the mobile market of course.

Edit:

I'm hoping for months now that all major companies just sue each other into checkmate until it becomes obvious to the governments that the patent system has to change. Please Apple, MS, Google, etc. sue until you are not allowed to sell any products anymore! I very much look forward to it.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by ryanmolden on Saturday May 26, 2012 @04:28PM (#4028255)
I believe Android leads only in a pure device count kind of way. Apple leads (far and away) in terms of profit per device, and that is the interesting metric for all large corporations. Google's Android play has always seemed defensive to avoid getting locked out of search if usage patterns on mobile shifted to non-web based interactions. Google does NOT want Apple, Microsoft or anyone else stepping between them and their users, especially since they make money with ad targeting/serving. As for Apple selling luxury toys to the well heeled, I recall reading recently that tablet manufacturers have all but admitted they can't price compete with the iPad. If Apple starts lowering prices to move down market, with their impressive vertical integration, I think it would be a blood bath for people currently in those spaces. I suspect we will see moves like this before the year is out. Not a good time to be Dell, Asus, etc...
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by jan_g on Saturday May 26, 2012 @04:46PM (#4028309)
>Apple leads (far and away) in terms of profit per device, and that is the interesting metric for all large corporations.

And this is exactly why I find it quite baffling that Apple are suing like madmen in the recent years.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by ryanmolden on Saturday May 26, 2012 @05:36PM (#4028446)
They have a position they feel is worth defending. I don't see this move (and to be clear, it is a distasteful move) as anything other than piling obstacles in the way of current or potential competitors. It is easier to prevent a competitor from rising up than it is to combat one that already has a foothold. I doubt this is a significant part of any strategy on their part other than "throw molotov cocktails all around to keep competitors busy/distracted". I would like companies to compete on merit and win by, you know, convincing consumers their offering is the best. Current corporate culture seems to view that kind of outlook as quaint or naive and prefers this kind of ass-hattery. I continue to hope for an eventual attainment of more sophisticated outlooks. The fact that such retarded, petty shit continues thousands of years into organized society is discouraging.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by dminor on Sunday May 27, 2012 @12:23AM (#4029226)
It goes back to their battles with Microsoft over the graphical desktop. Apple's hypersensitivity to perceived copying has been baked into their company DNA.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by greedo on Sunday May 27, 2012 @02:07PM (#4030632)
"Apples (sic) position for years?" Apple has NEVER held the market lead in smartphones. They've been a minority of the market since the introduction of the iPhone in 2007.

And your description of the "niche that Apple occupies" in nonsensical.

Yes, Apple has had a major advantage for years; the iPod was very well designed, as was the iPhone. And funny enough, you should be impressed because they've already thought "of the next big thing(tm)." It's called the iPad. You might have seen one here and there.

If you seriously think that Apple is successful because it builds fancy products, that their walled garden is anything but a success, and that there is "only little space left in the niche" for Apple to grow in, you haven't been paying attention.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by buster on Monday May 28, 2012 @03:45AM (#4032387)
That's your point of view. You may not have paid attention to the competition growth over the last years. Where is your reasoning that Apple will dominate the tablet space for the coming years? Do you seriously believe, that what happened in the mobile space, won't happen in the tablet space? Then you're just ignorant. And Apple knows that. Apple is arming itself and will defend itself in the court. That was my reasoning in my original post.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by greedo on Monday May 28, 2012 @02:25PM (#4034428)
No, it's not my point of view, it's a fact. Apple has never held the majority of smartphone market share.

And my reasoning that Apple will dominate the tablet space is because they have sold arguably the best tablet in numbers that dwarf any other vendor, or all other vendors combined. With the iOS ecosystem supporting it, the chances of another vendor usurping the iPad's lead in the next five years is unlikely.

And what has happened in the mobile space? Apple introduces a smartphone with the goal of 10% of the market. They have had year over year growth in that market, and now are in the mid 30's of share percentage. They dominate the smartphone market when it comes to extracting profit, and have one singular competitor, Samsung, who is beating them in "shipped" units.

If Apple were so unfortunate to have the tablet market follow what it has done in the smartphone market, there will be a lot of happy Apple shareholders in the future.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by buster on Monday May 28, 2012 @05:22PM (#4034980)
I can almost see the Reality Distortion Field(tm) around you.
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by greedo on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @10:44AM (#4037682)
Ad hominem. Why not put up some facts to dispute what I'm posting?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by moldbug on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:53PM (#4028028)
The latter?

"Moderate" is always relative to standard industry practice. If patent trolling isn't standard industry practice quite yet, it's fast getting there. "Don't be evil" is a lot harder when evil is the norm.

Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by 3am on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:08PM (#4027920)
I don't know any better than you, but it looks a lot like it's intended to harass Google (edit: without dragging down Apple's brand)
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by SkyMarshal on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:15PM (#4027942)
That was my first thought as well, but Rockstar is not just going after Google but carpet-bombing the entire technology world (phones, routers, etc - anything). So why would Apple be on board with that?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by 3am on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:23PM (#4027961)
Collateral damage?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by culturestate on Saturday May 26, 2012 @02:19PM (#4027949)
My knee-jerk response was "an escalation of Apple's holy war on Android," but perhaps this is the first phase in a deescalation. Tim Cook has said he prefers to settle rather than battle, and what better way to bring HTC and Samsung to the table than with the acquisition of a not-so-subtle guillotine forged from key LTE patents?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by Steko on Saturday May 26, 2012 @05:11PM (#4028377)
How is this really any different than all of these companies (and many others) investing in IV? or are those "investments" effectively just the licensing fees to the IV pool?
Re:Apple And Microsoft Behind Patent Troll Armed With Thousa... by fpgeek on Sunday May 27, 2012 @10:36PM (#4031701)
My understanding is the most of IV's "investors" didn't buy or otherwise provide the patents that IV uses (which does suggest the payments are closer to licensing fees than true investments). With Rockstar, we have specific players (Apple, Ericsson, Microsoft, RIM, Sony) buying the patents and funding the troll in the first place.