News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Saturday May 04, 2024 @04:58PM (#40260226)
most buildings in america are concrete and/or brick, though the usa is an exception. in most of america, wood is used only for roofs and illegal slums, and even most slums are mostly brick

i don't know what the situation is on other continents but i've sure seen a lot of photos and videos of concrete and brick buildings

Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by pclmulqdq on Saturday May 04, 2024 @07:26PM (#40261117)
Disregarding the houses, the most popular form of apartment building in the US right now is called a "5 over 1" which has a wood frame on top of a concrete first floor. The facades often aren't wood, but the buildings themselves are usually wood. Most "brick" houses in the US have a brick facade over a wooden house.

The few exceptions are in the densest cities in the US, like New York, where new construction is concrete and steel.

Canada, I am sure, is the same. Mexico and South America, not so sure. I have been around some places in Central America that have tons of wood construction, and so did the parts of Argentina and Brazil I have seen, but you may have better information. Many houses that you think are concrete or brick actually have a wood frame.

Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by lock-the-spock on Saturday May 04, 2024 @08:10PM (#40261363)
Even the concrete and steel houses often start with wood framing of some sort and end with wood as a structural part of any ceilings and roofs. Not to mention stairs, room structures/interior walls, ...
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Sunday May 05, 2024 @02:43PM (#40267150)
yes, as i said, the usa is an exception. canada is the same as the usa but has a very small number of buildings. argentina, brazil, perú, ecuador, and most of central america are almost entirely reinforced concrete frames filled in with cheap hollow brick and maybe decorated with wood paneling. very poor areas and luxury cabins are sometimes exceptions, and possibly that's where you went in central america

remember there's a billion people living in america. only a third of those are in the usa, and the people in the usa are much more urbanized, meaning less buildings per person. canada is another 4% of the total american population. so roughly three quarters of the buildings in america are outside the usa and canada

Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by rootusrootus on Saturday May 04, 2024 @07:54PM (#40261272)
My impression is that concrete must be cheaper than wood, given that wood seems mostly used in high income countries and concrete is dominant in low income areas.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Sunday May 05, 2024 @02:17PM (#40266967)
it's a somewhat complicated comparison to make, but i think basically the answer is yes

there's also a coincidental factor, though; wood is cheap where forests are abundant, and although having abundant natural resources such as arable land and wood doesn't guarantee wealth, exhausting your natural resources through deforestation and desertification virtually guarantees poverty.

as for 'cheaper', well, the numerator is dollars, but what's the denominator? i would say it's 'house', but neither concrete nor wood is sold by the house; cement and sand and gravel and rebar are sold by the kilo, and wood is sold by the square meter. so we need some way to make them comparable

one approach is to try to compute 'cost per strength', on the theory that a house's worth of materials is enough materials to be strong enough to work as a house. but there are two different kinds of strength involved here. floors and roofs must resist flexure without breaking, and materialswise, that mostly depends on the material's tensile strength. they also must resist impact loadings, which depends on tensile strength but also flexibility: a more flexible floor can elastically absorb a greater impact energy before reaching the same tensile strain, and a tougher material is one that has a higher elastic energy capacity in this sense. walls, on the other hand, mostly must resist compression from above, and typically this mostly depends on their ability to resist buckling, not their material compressive strength. resisting buckling depends on not strength but stiffness: the material of the buckling beam must not bend far enough that the beam's effective compressive stiffness starts to decrease, causing it to bend further

a lot of people confuse strength and stiffness; i recommend watching the first demo in dan gelbart's https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtxA20Q-Uss, although for most of us it took a lot more than that to get enlightened

reinforced concrete (either pretensioned or in compression) gets its stiffness from sand and gravel, which are cheap as dirt (most of the cost of sand is the truck that delivers it to your building site) and its tensile strength from steel. i think the answer is that steel is in fact very much cheaper than wood per unit of either tensile strength or toughness

on the other hand, people usually build concrete walls to be much, much stiffer than wood-framed walls, so it's common for a given area of wood-framed wall to cost less than the same area of concrete wall. to compensate for this, people very commonly build the floors and frame of a building with reinforced concrete, then fill in the walls with cheap hollow brick. this is i think cheaper than a similarly non-load-bearing wood-frame wall made out of 2×4s and drywall, but not by that much

on the gripping hand, galvanized steel studs are cheaper than wooden 2×4s, and they're starting to become popular for low-cost construction, covered with drywall or cementboard

Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by pvaldes on Sunday May 05, 2024 @05:48PM (#40268789)
There is a lot of wood in all houses even in North Concretia. Every house is filled with wood furniture.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by retrac on Saturday May 04, 2024 @06:02PM (#40260639)
Many modern brick buildings, have a wood structure with steel brackets, and the brick is only facing, and is not what is holding up the roof. Older brick homes do have brick structural walls or pillars inside, but in recent decades those are usually re-enforced concrete blocks.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Saturday May 04, 2024 @06:23PM (#40260778)
that is sometimes true in a few countries like the usa, but in most of america they have a reinforced concrete structure rather than a wood one. new structural brick is quite rare because brick is weak and expensive
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by xboxnolifes on Saturday May 04, 2024 @05:07PM (#40260282)
In dense US cities maybe. Most US homes are built with wood. ~90% of US home constructions are wood framed.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Saturday May 04, 2024 @06:20PM (#40260762)
in the comment you are replying to, i specifically said that the usa is an exception to this general rule
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by xboxnolifes on Saturday May 04, 2024 @07:58PM (#40261283)
Ah, I misread. I rarely come across america used to refer to the collective continents.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by mc32 on Saturday May 04, 2024 @08:13PM (#40261376)
The collective continents are not America, but The Americas, given that it is collection or South America and North America with an isthmus connecting them. I believe Brazilian Portuguese and South American Spanish also use the plural to refer to the set of continents.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Saturday May 04, 2024 @08:51PM (#40261514)
no
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by amanaplanacanal on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:03AM (#40263098)
I was under the impression that the plural was common in English, but the singular was more common in Spanish. I could certainly be wrong though.
Re:Was the Stone Age the Wood Age? by kragen on Sunday May 05, 2024 @02:44PM (#40267156)
yeah, in spanish and portuguese, generally america is considered to be one continent, not two. https://es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Am%C3%A9rica begins, for example, "America is the second largest continent on Earth, after Asia."

basically there's a lot of cluelessness going around in this thread by people who've apparently never thought about things like where amerigo vespucci sailed to, what columbus is said to have discovered (by landing where), where the members of the organization of american states are located, where the pan-american highway goes, etc.