News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick?

Hey guys, I've just built a website for one of my clients and they hired a marketing team who suggested them different design then the one i made. Can you tell me you opinion since i don't like what marketing team come up with, and would like to do some sort of poll to suggest a proper one for my client.

Here is my current design: http://www.investorwatchdog.com

And this is a design that marketing team suggested: http://bit.ly/KHwuDP

( 8 comments | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by shane_armstrong on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:45PM (#4024621)
The original one is better, but the font for your links is extremely malformed in my Chrome for some reason.

Except from that I prefer it, it is less conforming and therefore will stick in my mind for longer, I actually read some of the text on your site, which is more than I usually did.

Tell your client the marketing team suggested that design so that they have a reason to be paid and that any marketing team is actually useless in most cases. Paying someone to tell you your own opinion is a bad method of outsourcing.

Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by usaphp on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:52PM (#4024656)
Hi Shane, thank you very much for you feedback, i really appreciate it. I totally agree with you.

p.s. what version of Chrome are you using?

Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by shane_armstrong on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:56PM (#4024674)
12.0.742.112 And you are most welcome, also, your top links "blog" anchor seems to be miss-placed.
Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by usaphp on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:47PM (#4024889)
thanks :) Will investigate on it right now. This is how it looks for me btw: http://bit.ly/JiazUb
Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by shane_armstrong on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:56PM (#4024936)
http://i48.tinypic.com/17eh3p.png

That is the view on my screen, a quick analysis of your page source shows that the container has a fixed width of 700px, but that the computed style is returning a total of 702px for all the contents of the spans.

This may be because your font size is forcing the containers to expand ever so slightly, try a 0.9em size compared to your general font size to see if this fixes the issue.

Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by usaphp on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:47PM (#4025123)
fonts are probably messed up on windows :) Thank you Shane for the feedback and for the time you spent to respond. I will just use a regular font instead...Still cant change a clients opinion :) she still likes the other one more ... dont have enought responds here :(
Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by shane_armstrong on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:35PM (#4025275)
Just wanted to say that the bug I reported with the site has now been fixed on windows Chrome, as well as the layour issue with the change of font you made.

Good look with your site :)

Re:Ask HN: Which design of a website should my client pick? by usaphp on Saturday May 26, 2012 @10:58AM (#4027405)
Thanks Shane :)