Re:Hello Downloader
by boboblong on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:41AM
(#4022100)
If Person A buys a song, rips it, and puts it on bittorrent, when Person B downloads one or more copies he has not stolen anything from anyone nor broken any contract with anyone.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hello Downloader
by waterlesscloud on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:51AM
(#4022120)
He has stolen the time and effort of the person who created the song.
This is not hard to understand. You may choose not to understand it, but you're playing a game with yourself that the rest of us are not obligated to accept.
The time and effort were already expended. You can't steal those anymore than you can "steal" a digital file you made a copy of.
If I build an app and sell it for a $1 and someone purchases it for that amount and then makes a copy for his friend I have simply missed out on revenue, but my time wasn't stolen nor was my app.