News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On software communities, "Rock star" programmers, and... ... by vacri on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:44PM (#4020982)
To be patronizing and demeaning require intent.

That intent need not be conscious. Second-class citizens the world over suffer from being demeaned without conscious effort.

What you should have said in your first comment is what you said here: why you think it's low quality. I do not agree with you about your several 'no one is arguing', because I think that they are. If you phrase it the way you do philosophically, of course people will say they're not doing that, but in their criticism of Tovalds (/RMS/whoever), many folks refuse to take content because of context. While no-one is saying he should take bad code to be nice, there is a sentiment of opinion-as-a-democracy.

Your counterexample is just as bad as that you decry because instead of Torvalds style (blunt but informative), you were just saying "I'm ignoring your comments without giving you any reasons". If I submit something and it's rejected, I'd much rather receive the former than the latter, because then at least I know why. Would people really prefer a stoic Torvalds that just stonewalled commits he didn't like without explaining why?

There are no comments on this comment yet.