Re:You can't just assume UTF-8
by kelnos on Tuesday April 30, 2024 @01:22AM
(#40207503)
The article addresses this, that current thinking in many places is that the robustness principle / Postel's Law maybe wasn't the best idea.
If you reject malformed input, then the person who created it has to go back and fix it and try again. If you interpret malformed input the best you can (and get it right), then everyone else implementing the same thing in the future now also has to implement your heuristics and workarounds. The malformed input effectively becomes a part of the spec.
This is why HTML & CSS are the garbage dump they are today, and why different browsers still don't always display pages exactly alike. The reason HTML5 exists is because people finally just gave up and decided to standardize all the broken behavior that was floating around in the wild. Pre-HTML5, the web was an outright dumpster fire of browser compatibility issues (as opposed to the mere garbage dump we have today).
Anyway, it's not really important to try to convince you that Postel's Law is bad; what's important is that you know that many people are starting to think it's bad, and there's no longer any strong consensus that it was ever a good thing.
If you reject malformed input, then the person who created it has to go back and fix it and try again. If you interpret malformed input the best you can (and get it right), then everyone else implementing the same thing in the future now also has to implement your heuristics and workarounds. The malformed input effectively becomes a part of the spec.
This is why HTML & CSS are the garbage dump they are today, and why different browsers still don't always display pages exactly alike. The reason HTML5 exists is because people finally just gave up and decided to standardize all the broken behavior that was floating around in the wild. Pre-HTML5, the web was an outright dumpster fire of browser compatibility issues (as opposed to the mere garbage dump we have today).
Anyway, it's not really important to try to convince you that Postel's Law is bad; what's important is that you know that many people are starting to think it's bad, and there's no longer any strong consensus that it was ever a good thing.