If a company takes out a loan from the bank, the bank isn’t putting up existing money, it just creates a new asset and starts accounting for it. Hence new money is created from nothing.
What stops the bank from creating too many loans is that the bank would become insolvent and all the workers have to carry their stuff out in cardboard boxes (except the execs they probably have someone to do that for them).
> If a company takes out a loan from the bank, the bank isn’t putting up existing money, it just creates a new asset and starts accounting for it. Hence new money is created from nothing.
Sorry, your analogy doesn't work out, because the roles are reversed.
Look at the situation where a company sells me a bond, to be paid back in ten years. But instead of me handing money over to them, I give them an IOU (or credit line) that they can draw down any time they wish to.
We can create this pair of bond and IOU out of nothing, just like the bank can create deposit-loan pairs out of nothing.
However, just like with the bank, people don't borrow money to let it just sit there. They want to invest.
So they spend their deposit, and draw down their IOU.
And once your customer does that, you better have some money in your 'safe' that you can hand to them.
In the classic case, that money comes from outside deposits.
> What stops the bank from creating too many loans is that the bank would become insolvent and all the workers have to carry their stuff out in cardboard boxes (except the execs they probably have someone to do that for them).
How would they go insolvent in your model?
DR Loan, CR Deposit.
Job done.
No need to issue bonds or do anything. It's just splitting the zero in accounting.
Any operation can do that. Generally there is legislation that then brings these 'deposit holders' under specific requirements.
> Job done.
You can do that, sure. And if that was all there was to banking, it would be a fantastic business to be in.
Alas, the whole point of taking out a loan is to spend the money on something, eg to invest it.
And once the bank's customer withdraws the deposit half of that newly created pair of anti-particles, the situation isn't nearly as symmetrical and neat anymore: the bank better have some money in the vault to be able to satisfy that withdrawal request.
(Slightly less antiquated: the customer will likely spend their borrowed money electronically, but then just means that you need to have the funds available to settle with the bank who runs the account on the receiving end of that transaction.)
> Generally there is legislation that then brings these 'deposit holders' under specific requirements.
Even without legislation or specific requirements, you can't just keep creating these loan/deposit pairs out of thin air. At least not, if your customers are supposed to be able to spend their borrowed funds.
Withdrawing is always just transferring to another bank - even if that bank is the central bank.
Banks settle with each other by the target bank taking over the deposit in the source bank. That is how correspondent banking has worked for at least four hundred years.
Everything else is a collateral optimisation.
There is never any "money" in a vault. There might be some receipts for money, but that's about it.
No. You can withdraw cash. But you are right, that the common case is a transfer.
> Banks settle with each other by the target bank taking over the deposit in the source bank.
That's one way they can settle. But at the end of the day (or whatever the relevant period is), they send each other the net difference in the underlying base money. These days, that's deposits at the central bank.
> That is how correspondent banking has worked for at least four hundred years.
Correspondent banking being important is mostly an American thing (and perhaps a 18th and 19th century English, but not Scottish, thing, too.)
> There is never any "money" in a vault. There might be some receipts for money, but that's about it.
These days, the 'vault' is (mostly) an account at the central bank.
(And if banks could create loans from 'nothing', so could any other company that can issues bonds.)
There have been episodes in history with very lightly regulated banks, and they were very stable banking systems by and large. See the 'free banking episodes' in eg Canada, Scotland, Australia and China. There was no 'creating loans from nothing' that needed to be regulated away.