News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cleaning Up Speech Recognition with GPT by rahimnathwani on Friday April 26, 2024 @09:03PM (#40176122)
Whisperx is great for English, and there's minimal cleanup to do at the end. (Diarization makes it take much longer, and sometimes you get a bunch of repeated phrases, but transcript-only is good.)

But for other languages, especially those with a variety of dialects (like Arabic), the output can be really hard to read. Interestingly, gpt-3.5-turbo can turn a garbled Arabic call transcript into a decent English summary. I guess this is due to the amount of redundancy/repetition in phone calls.

I wonder whether anyone knows of something better than Whisper Large v2/v3 for Arabic ASR?

I had a look recently, and what I found was:

- Among published multilingual models (i.e. ignoring English-only models), it seems that Whisper Large has the lowest (best) overall WER (word error rate).

- Although Facebook published a multilingual model (mms-1b-all) that outperforms Whisper on many less common languages, its Arabic WER on standard benchmarks is much worse than that of Whisper, so I don't think it's worth trying on my data.

- There's a paper from ~6 months ago by some researchers who claimed to get slightly better performance than Whisper vanilla, but their code is not public, and I can't find any blog posts or articles talking about using their work.

- Googling turned up some attempts to finetune mms-1b-all with Arabic, but nothing I found included any WER data, so I assume these attempts didn't work out.

Re:Cleaning Up Speech Recognition with GPT by jilijeanlouis on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:17AM (#40177974)
That’s a bit problem with Arabic especially because of dialects and the lack of good datasets (when I say I mean robust - including noisy dirty audios).Would you mind testing gladia.io and give feedbacks ?
Re:Cleaning Up Speech Recognition with GPT by rahimnathwani on Saturday April 27, 2024 @10:28PM (#40185497)
Before I try it out, would you mind sharing any info about your models' WER on Arabic, compared with Whisper Large V2?
Re:Cleaning Up Speech Recognition with GPT by rrsp on Saturday April 27, 2024 @04:38AM (#40178368)
“- There's a paper from ~6 months ago by some researchers who claimed to get slightly better performance than Whisper vanilla, but their code is not public, and I can't find any blog posts or articles talking about using their work.”

Have you got a link to this paper?

Re:Cleaning Up Speech Recognition with GPT by rahimnathwani on Saturday April 27, 2024 @11:02AM (#40180478)