Also a 1Password passkey user. It is the most portable implementation of passkeys I've used. Still, if you want portability with passkeys you have to trust some company to sync them. I don't want to need to rely on Google, Apple, or Microsoft to sync my keys because those platforms all have some lock-in. Guess 1Password is a form of vendor lock-in too, but it is one I don't mind.

I don't think we should consider passkeys failed already. The widespread rollout just got started, and the ecosystem hasn't had a chance to catch up. Give it some time, and see if things get better.