News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by zora_goron on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:08AM (#40169620)
I commented on this on HN a couple months ago, but I had a similar conclusion regarding the value of memorization when I joined med school after studying computer science in undergrad and grad.

It took me a while to buy in to high-volume memorization as a learning technique (especially coming from CS, where memorizing facts is not a huge emphasis). After a while though, I started recognizing how the quick recall encouraged by the system enhanced my understanding of concepts vs replacing it (I wrote about this a couple years ago [0]).

[0] https://samrawal.substack.com/p/on-the-relationship-between-...

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:40AM (#40169916)
That's my takeaway from The Shallows by Nicholas Carr. Knowing how to derive information or where to find information doesn't mean you know the information and knowing the information is necessary to form higher level associations in the mind.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by JonChesterfield on Friday April 26, 2024 @12:20PM (#40171177)
Huh. That's an interesting premise. I think I would split it though - knowing the basis well enough to derive results is probably fine for later deduction, knowing where to find the information is definitely useless for it.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by nescioquid on Friday April 26, 2024 @05:16PM (#40174402)
The argument is actually more about insight. You can't have insights about things you don't already have in your head. Insight in this context is noticing some new relationship between two facts.

There was a slang term "refrigerator thoughts" that described someone staring into the refrigerator while thinking of a show plot and realizing there is a plot hole, a disturbing implication, etc. In any case, that's an example of insight. Hopefully we have these spontaneous realizations about less trivial things as well.

The more stuff you've got in your head, the more insights you'll have, which drive more questions whose investigations puts yet more stuff in your head.

I don't think you can split it. The critical piece is actually getting information into your head in the first place.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by bitwize on Friday April 26, 2024 @12:31PM (#40171313)
"Oh, and check this out: I'm a bloody genius now! Estás usando este software de traducción de forma incorrecta. Por favor, consulta el manual. I don't even know what I just said, but I can find out!"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F3TG1AzBJYo

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by anon291 on Friday April 26, 2024 @06:00PM (#40174796)
I have sung the praises of memorization since I was a kid, and yet the attitude that, with the internet, memorization is no longer required because we have access to unending knowledge, seems oh so prevalent. One wonders what these advocates must think... do they claim to know Norwegian because they can use Google to translate at any particular instant, for example? One wonders what life might be like for people so confident in their non-existent abilities.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by wisty on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:57PM (#40175662)
A lot of education "experts" (people doing education research, policy and Ted talks) are usually privileged enough that their parents forced them to memorise enough phonics and times tables to get to college, and think that the teachers who tried to do the same were just wasting their precious time when they could have been doing interesting things like talking about philosophy.

Education as a discipline has no real knowledge or skills in the Anglosphere beyond basic essay writing. Historically teaching was a craft, taught in trade schools or on the job, but for various reasons it moved to university without universitiea having of the content developed, so universities took the low road and asked PhD candidates to essentially write essays on the philosophy of education so that's now the content.

Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach. And those who can't teach, teach teachers, and since the content is just writing essays on the philosophy of education their confidence in non-existent abilities is never pressure tested.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by willhslade on Friday April 26, 2024 @08:40PM (#40175988)
Can you suggest a culture that does it better and/or better methods? Your point of view meshes with mine and I have a young child and I'm worried about the education he's going to get in Canada.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by lannisterstark on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:10PM (#40176504)
Honestly? it's fine. Every culture does it differently and they all focus in x for lack of y. South Asian cultures for example treat their universities as job training centers (and generally tend to lack liberal arts and social education) whereas universities are ideally supposed to make you a well rounded person etc.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by wisty on Saturday April 27, 2024 @05:31AM (#40178620)
Spending 10 minutes a day on reading or math is probably fine, if you are 1:1 you can just problem solve most issues with a mainstream student, and if they are having major issues look at what special ed teachers do (they are way more scientific than mainstream teachers as they can't rely on the students componsate for bad teaching).

For older kids, it can be a bit tricky, as their goals and opinions will matter a lot more, but look into evidence based study habits for exams, and help them get assignments done with a decently efficient process I guess.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by dctoedt on Saturday April 27, 2024 @03:35PM (#40182755)
> Those who can, do. Those who can't, teach.

They're not mutually-exclusive sets. In professional schools (law, medicine, perhaps others), some of the best-regarded instructors are successful practitioners who teach on the side.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by Pedro_Ribeiro on Friday April 26, 2024 @07:48PM (#40175588)
I think you're being a little disingenuous here. Nobody claims to know Norwegian, it's just that the value of knowing it is not as valuable now that I can just use Google Translate to talk to a Norwegian.

I do agree that memorization is important, by the way. I just think that it's useless if you can't also derive your way there. Nothing wrong with having checkpoints in your mind though.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by dotnet00 on Friday April 26, 2024 @10:05PM (#40176467)
Memorization has its place, such as with medicine or language learning. But the issue most people are referring to when deriding memorization is about memorization that is done for the sake of busy work alone.

In school I was tested on memorizing a map and drawing precise borders, rivers etc and various acronyms that were obsolete even at that time. They added 0 value to my education, except as unnecessary stress in having to memorize them. Similarly with being expected to memorize various physics and math theorems such that understanding was treated as having zero value (that is, if your wording isn't exactly the same as in the textbook, it doesn't matter if your answer is actually perfectly correct in terms of understanding). It was to the point of being prescribed several arbitrary essays to memorize, with one of them being randomly expected to be reproduced in an exam.

None of that added any value, most of it turned out to be hilariously divorced from real life expectations.

Even with your disingenuous example of language learning. People who argue that they don't need to learn the language because they can just use a translation app are making the point that they aren't interested in learning the language and have limited enough need to interact in it to get by with just a translator. Anyone who has actually interacted with a language they don't know understands that translation software doesn't obsolete knowing a language.

Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by purpleteam81 on Sunday April 28, 2024 @03:19AM (#40186696)
True, that is rote learning. It can be the basis of critical thinking. Critical thinking involves methods of inquiry...who, what, why, when and how. Rote thinking is limited to 'how'.
Re:I Rewired My Brain to Become Fluent in Math (2014) by Aerbil313 on Friday April 26, 2024 @04:54PM (#40174170)
Related thread a while back: "Learning Is Remembering": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32982513