News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by anigbrowl on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:17PM (#40160353)
Serious question: why aren't false DMCA claims prosecutable as fraud? The elements are there - a knowingly false representation, detrimental reliance, and materiality.
Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by wil421 on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:23PM (#40160432)
Because the DMCA is for them not us.
Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by davikr on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:38PM (#40160646)
It should be required, by law, to accompany a DMCA claim with some kind of digital signature that can certify the issuer really owns the content (such as a company or law office certificate). Other than that, they're prosecutable as perjury, but in practice, no one ever inquires those cases.
Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by jsheard on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:26PM (#40160492)
Garry has now clarified that the takedowns were in fact issued by Nintendo, contrary to earlier reports.

https://twitter.com/garrynewman/status/1783501547361411494

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:40PM (#40160671)
Hilariously, there are people there yelling it can’t be true.

To which:

A. Why would he have lied?

B. This has had millions of views across all platforms. If it wasn’t real, don’t you think Nintendo would be calling up and telling him that it was fake?

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by kalium-xyz on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:46PM (#40160737)
Thought I don't think its rational to think its fake I do want to add:

A: Its Garry. He used to go onto community servers and grief cause hes a troll and might find it funny to fan the flames.

B: If people think they are doing it anyways they might as well actually start pressing claims.

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by Justsignedup on Thursday April 25, 2024 @02:32PM (#40161287)
The barrier of proof for a bogus DMCA is incredibly high. Even something like "our system sends out 100k takedowns a day, so it had to be automaded and sometimes we face false positives" is enough to shut down a case.

DMCA has many problems and needs to be updated for 20 years now. Remember the DECSS issues faced?

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by matheusmoreira on Thursday April 25, 2024 @10:06PM (#40165211)
> we face false positives

> enough to shut down a case

... It boggles my mind that this could ever be considered an acceptable defense in any court.

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by throwawaymobule on Thursday April 25, 2024 @01:25PM (#40160472)
I think it's only Nintendo that'd be able to go after someone sending claims in their name.

It'd likely be hard to find whoever sent a false notice on general, since there's no identity or address verification needed to send one.

Re:Garry's Mod faces deluge of Nintendo-related DMCA takedow... by matheusmoreira on Thursday April 25, 2024 @10:04PM (#40165196)
Because copyright monopolists have trillions of dollars which they use to pay lobbyists and essentially buy laws such as the DMCA which says that you can issue a take down and it's up to poor sap on the receiving end to either submit or fight a costly legal battle to prove not just their innocence but their bad faith.