News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:5 Weeks of Go by stock_toaster on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @12:32PM (#4013813)

  > Yes, but everyone I know who does real work with Objects knows that the
  > textbook definitions aren't what people do with real systems. That 
  > makes it sound like the author only knows the textbook definitions.
Phrases like 'who does real work' and 'people do with real systems' makes it sound a bit like a 'no-true-scotsman'. I imagine that was not your intent.

Anyway, I think the point is that the common perception of object systems are likely those commonly used in Java, C++, and C#. I say 'likely' simply because I am guessing that those are the more popular by volume of code written. Go has a different approach than those.

Re:5 Weeks of Go by stcredzero on Wednesday May 23, 2012 @01:07PM (#4014015)
...real systems' makes it sound a bit like a 'no-true-scotsman'

Isn't there a meta-fallacy here? Sometimes there are things that experienced people don't say, but some, like inexperienced undergraduates, do.

Anyway, I think the point is that the common perception of object systems are likely those commonly used in Java, C++, and C#. I say 'likely' simply because I am guessing that those are the more popular by volume of code written. Go has a different approach than those.

There may be some selection bias here. "Everyone I know who does real work with Objects" is by happenstance mostly working in Smalltalk. The pragmatic approach most people take there involves quite a bit of duck typing. (And lots of grousing about how those interfaces aren't documented.) There's also a lot of bad legacy code that needs a refactoring cluestick there too, tbh.