News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No one buys books by iamacyborg on Monday April 22, 2024 @05:46PM (#40121452)
Paper books are also just orders of magnitude easier to flip through and re-read specific chapters, paragraphs or sections.

I can skim through a shelf full of books in a way that I’m just not able to with ebooks, even with stuff like full text search available in Calibre.

Re:No one buys books by SubmarineClub on Monday April 22, 2024 @06:17PM (#40122990)
Another benefit to paper books, in my experience, is it's a lot easier to remember the rough location of a particular passage (towards the front, middle, near the end, etc.) than with digital

A progress bar really doesn't replace the context of the stack of pages behind and ahead of your current page.

Re:No one buys books by maximilianthe1 on Monday April 22, 2024 @08:17PM (#40127104)
While physical "progress bar" is much easier to remeber than digital one (on the side of the screen for pdfs), because you actually interact with it the whole time, i don't find (ha) finding a particular passage hard without it. I personally usually can remeber a phrase or just a word and search for them in a PDF to find the needed passage.
Re:No one buys books by UncleOxidant on Monday April 22, 2024 @07:33PM (#40126290)
It's pretty easy to highlight passages with most e-reader software. Some even let you write a note that goes with the highlight. You can then look through a list of all highlighted passages.
Re:No one buys books by Tor3 on Monday April 22, 2024 @11:30PM (#40128157)
It's when something comes up and you remember that you read something relevant in the past. In most of those cases it's not about "Ah, this is something I may want to check again at a later time, so let's highlight it". So, there's no list of highlighted passages to search through.

Indeed this is one of those things I miss about paper books. When the above happens I have a terrible time finding that on my Kindle. Most of the time I'm not able to, while with a paper book I didn't have that problem, mostly.

Re:No one buys books by dhosek on Monday April 22, 2024 @09:44PM (#40127587)
My own personal anecdata on this comes from being able to find a passage I read in a 500-page book in 1992 for a class I was taking in 1998. I could probably even find that same passage now if I were to walk across the room to the bookcase where I have that book.

Although on the other hand, I was also able to turn up an article I’d read online a couple years later when it was relevant to a friend’s relationship with her newly out trans kid, but it was definitely a different sort of recall and lookup happening in the latter case.

Re:No one buys books by skydhash on Monday April 22, 2024 @06:26PM (#40123053)
I classify skimming as a "distracting" activity. I always ask myself: What information do I need? And then it's very easy to get to the relevant passage. And outlines are there for a reason (PDF Expert can edit them) so navigating between the same file is not that cumbersome for me. I do agree that the experience is more pleasant with a paper book, but in a focused session, the result is pretty much the same.

Skimming is great for building a mental map, but that is a separate activity than reading to learn. And it can be done digitally too, just differently.

Re:No one buys books by Ferret7446 on Monday April 22, 2024 @09:00PM (#40127332)
That's a software choice issue. You can definitely flip through digital texts more easily than physical. With a decent monitor, you can flip through multiple books at the same time which is quite difficult to do with physical books, assuming you haven't summoned eldritch appendages to help.
Re:No one buys books by wolverine876 on Monday April 22, 2024 @07:41PM (#40126855)
> Paper books are also just orders of magnitude easier to flip through and re-read specific chapters, paragraphs or sections.

Whatever works for you, of course. PDFs have bookmarks, which instantly take me to a specific spot on a specific page. Also, I can open multiple instances of the PDF, viewing multiple pages of the same book (or some PDF readers allow split screens to do the same thing). Edit: And if I don't recall where something is, I can search for it.

Re:No one buys books by Tor3 on Monday April 22, 2024 @11:34PM (#40128179)
I prefer PDFs for informative material (various documentation), though they're less useful if it's just a photocopied old manual (no OCR).

It's when reading books (literature, not documentation) that the e-readers have something going for them. I read nearly all my books on the Kindle, but I never use it for documentation - I've tried, that's just cumbersome. PDFs on a PC are fine.