News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by tedunangst on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:24PM (#40116558)
You don't necessarily have to host the comments on your server. But by providing an AP id, you provide a common reference for other people to refer to.
Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by Hamuko on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:35PM (#40116666)
Isn't the post URL already a common reference for other people to refer to? That's how I've seen people link to my site and discuss my blog post.
Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by aprilnya on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:43PM (#40116741)
Sure, but with AP all the comments could be in one thread instead of being dozens of threads on different sites
Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by Hamuko on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:44PM (#40116751)
Can I as the owner of the site moderate those comments if they're linked to the canonical reference to my site and appear next to my content when viewed outside my site?
Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by aprilnya on Monday April 22, 2024 @01:55PM (#40116867)
Someone correct me if I’m wrong, but

You can moderate what can be seen from your site (and what your site will return when asked for comments on that post by other sites(?)), but you can’t moderate it completely when viewed on other sites — i.e. if you’re Site A, someone comments something you don’t like on Site B, and someone looks at the comments from Site C, if Site B and C were already federating with each other then C will see B’s comment (and in this case it’s Site C’s responsibility to moderate)

You can block a specific user of Site B from viewing your posts in the future, but it’s up to Site B’s software to actually respect that. But if it doesn’t (this is rare, most software does respect things like this and it’s only tiny forks that disable this functionality), you can also just block Site B entirely

Editing to expand: Yes, this is pretty wonky and basically means you can only control what’s seen on your site unless you go through a lot of effort, but without ActivityPub you can’t control what other people say about your post on other sites either (i.e. you can’t moderate the HN thread of your article)

Re:Ghost Is Federating over ActivityPub by Vinnl on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @05:34AM (#40130157)
I think if someone on Mastodon comments on a Ghost blog, then Mastodon will tell Ghost that they did so (via ActivityPub).

Then if someone on Pixelfed sees that blog, Pixelfed will ask Ghost who has commented on it (via ActivityPub). Ghost can then tell them about that (via ActivityPub) - or it can choose not to do so (based on its own moderation tools).

That doesn't mean that the Mastodon comment no longer exists, nor that it is invisible to the people looking at the Mastodon comment (similar to HN comments), but Ghost won't boost its reach.

So what ActivityPub gives you is the option to reshare comments.